Ep. 175-What Happened to Gayle McCaffrey and Lisa McBride?
When 36-year-old Gayle McCaffrey went missing from West Ashley, South Carolina in 2012, her family knew she wouldn't have willingly abandoned her children. Her husband Bob's description of an argument...
17 Apr 23min
Ep. 174-The Murder of Janet Abaroa in Durham
On April 26, 2005, Raven Abaroa returned home from a recreational soccer game to find his 25-year-old wife, Janet, murdered in their home. Their six-month-old infant son was unharmed in a nearby bedro...
10 Apr 23min
Ep. 173-Springtime Disappearances in South Carolina
Renee shares three stories of springtime disappearances from the show catalogue, along with one new story of two teenagers who were lost at sea and rescued in 2005.Mentioned:Ep. 20-Missing from the Fr...
3 Apr 22min
Ep. 172-The Disappearance of Jimmy Dale Whitfield in South Carolina and Charlotte’s Unknown “Boxcar Boy”
In March of 1987, 29-year-old Jimmy Dale Whitfield went missing from his home in Seneca, S.C. after his wife told police they had an argument. Now the oldest missing persons case from Oconee County, i...
27 Mar 20min
Ep. 171-Jeffrey "The Roofman" Manchester
In the summer of 2004, an inmate in prison for armed robbery and kidnapping escaped from the Brown Creek Correctional Institution in Anson County. Authorities searched the surrounding area and Charlot...
20 Mar 29min
Replay-Four 1992 Deaths in Burke and Catawba Counties
In 1992, a 13-year-old from Hickory, North Carolina went missing from her home and was discovered murdered a few weeks later. Around the same time, three older women known to have high-risk lifestyles...
13 Mar 20min
Ep. 170-The Murder of Sherri Jackson in North Carolina
In November of 2006, 27-year-old Sherri Jackson went missing from Greensboro. Because her friends and family knew she was in the process of breaking things off with her boyfriend, they were immediatel...
6 Mar 18min
Ep. 169-Cases of Cyberstalking in the Carolinas
When Myrtle Beach resident Mica Miller died by suicide in 2024, her friends and family knew her estranged husband's harassment and behavior played a large part in her state of mind. In December 2025, ...
27 Feb 24min
