E10 Annabelle the Doll-y Parton Impersonator and the Tap Water Scammer
Come celebrate episode 10 with us! We’ve got the story of Annabelle the (extremely creepy) Doll and America’s first serial killer, the one and only H. H. Holmes. So many reasons to drink this week! L...
9 Apr 20171h 13min
E9 The Wandering Cowboy and the Pregnancy Pact, but for Boys
In episode 9, Em tells Christine about the Sallie House, botched surgeries, hoofprints, Gateway to Hell and all. Meanwhile, Christine tells the story of the indestructible Michael Malloy, which includ...
2 Apr 20171h 5min
Listener Stories: Vol. 2
In the second episode of listener stories, Em and Christine read some of the creepiest lisetener submissions yet. Hear some poignant stories from listeners with loved ones who’ve passed away, plus an ...
1 Apr 201740min
E8 Our First Fight and Franzia Stains…or Blood?
Episode 8 has arrived! Em tells Christine about the Queen Mary (and is pretty pissed that Christine went without her) and Christine tells Em the story of Maura Murray’s mysterious disappearance. Lear...
26 Mar 20171h 12min
E7 A Menorah Made of Lava and the Jerry Springer of Germany
EPISODE 7 IS HERE. Em tells Christine about the terrifying Eastern State Penitentiary and all its ghostly inhabitants, and Christine tells Em about one of Germany’s most chilling cold cases of all tim...
19 Mar 201755min
E6 The Human Hair Version and the Worst Social Studies Class Ever
In episode 6, Em watches Christine’s mind explode over the notorious story of Robert the Doll. Christine tells the story of the Elizabeth Smart kidnapping, reminding Em where she got her compulsion to...
12 Mar 20171h 8min
E5 The “Creepy Little Thing” and a Journey of Self-Destruction
In episode 5, Em and Christine have a casual chat about the poltergeist that tortured the Smurl family back in the 80s and everyone’s favorite killer clown, John Wayne Gacy. Christine not only learns ...
5 Mar 20171h 2min
Listener Stories: Vol. 1
In one of the creepiest episodes yet, Christine and Em read real-life paranormal and true crime stories sent in by our beautiful fans - YOU GUYS! As if these absurdly creepy stories weren’t enough, we...
1 Mar 201731min
