Ep 69 - Teri Jendusa Nicolai
This week’s case takes us to Wisconsin, where a seemingly routine meeting sets the stage for something far more disturbing. Teri Jendusa Nicolai is simply trying to navigate a difficult chapter in her...
17 Apr 1h
Ep 68 - Martha Moxley
We’re back — and we’re diving straight into a case that’s haunted true crime for decades. 🖤 In our first episode after months away, Murder with Millennials revisits the brutal 1975 killing of Martha ...
18 Feb 1h
Ep 67 - The Babes in the Woods
In 1986, two nine-year-old girls vanished while playing near their homes in the Moulsecoomb area of Brighton, England. The following day, their bodies were discovered in nearby woodland — a crime that...
24 Okt 202547min
Ep 66 - The Lundy Family Murders
In 2000, a quiet New Zealand town was rocked by the brutal murders of a mother and her young daughter in their own home. What followed was one of the country’s most controversial and emotionally charg...
16 Okt 20251h 2min
Ep 65 - John O'Keefe & Karen Read
On a cold January night in 2022, Boston police officer John O’Keefe was found dead in the snow outside a suburban home. His girlfriend, Karen Read, was quickly charged with his murder. But as the case...
9 Okt 20251h 3min
Ep 64 - Donna Perry
When three women were found murdered in Spokane in the early ’90s, the trail went cold for nearly two decades—until a surprising DNA match led detectives to Donna Perry, a woman with a violent crimina...
12 Sep 202554min
Ep 63 - Michelle MacNeil
In a seemingly quiet Utah neighborhood, behind the doors of a perfect-looking family home, a chilling secret was about to unravel. Michelle MacNeil—a beloved mother of eight, devout Mormon, and respec...
28 Aug 202547min
