Johnny Pius
In April 1979, 13-year-old Johnny Pius set out on his bicycle for a short ride to Dogwood Elementary School in Smithtown, New York. He never came home. The next day, his body was discovered in the woo...
1 Sep 202542min
Vanessa Ladouceur
On March 18, 2022, 30-year-old fitness instructor Vanessa Ladouceur was just steps from her downtown Calgary workplace when she was brutally attacked by a stranger with a knife.Support this podcast at...
25 Aug 202556min
The Tokars Murder
In 1992, Sara Tokars, a mother of two, was forced to watch her life crumble in the most unimaginable way—shot in front of her children just hours after returning from a family trip. But behind this br...
18 Aug 202534min
Brittany Zimmerman
In the quiet college town of Madison, Wisconsin, 21-year-old Brittany Zimmerman was on the brink of finishing her degree. A mishandled 9-11 call would be discovered that could have saved her.Now, year...
11 Aug 202529min
To Leslie with Love
One of my dearest friends Leslie co-hosted one of my first exclusive episodes with me, discussing the Erikkson Twins case. Sadly she lost her battle with cancer on July 20, 2025 and I felt the need to...
6 Aug 202555min
Edward Plantegenet
Edward wasn't the most well liked man, but many felt he didn't deserved to be murdered.Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/a-million-other-choices/exclusive-contentAdvertising Inquiries: h...
4 Aug 202533min
Charles Locke
He was the quiet neighbor who brought over food and lent a helping hand. But when a body turned up wrapped in a tarp, the trail of lies, duct tape, and deception led straight to a killer, who falls fo...
28 Jul 202547min
The Crimes of Melissa Shepard
She was charming, devout, and deadly. Melissa Ann Shepard, known as the “Internet Black Widow,” lured lonely widowers into her web of deceit—leaving a trail of poisoned ice cream, stolen fortunes, and...
21 Jul 202528min
