64 | Cara Knott | The Traffic Stop
The three mustaches feather their bangs and put on their best pair of parachute pants to talk about the strange murder of Cara Knott. Did a PSA from the 1980’s actually help catch her killer? Was it 1...
10 Apr 20251h 38min
63 | Jamie Lavis | Missing in Manchester
The three mustaches take a trip to jolly old England to discuss the mysterious disappearance of Jamie Lavis. Did the parents do it? Or was it the creepy, shirtless bus driver. You don't have to be She...
3 Apr 20251h 18min
62 | Christine Paolilla | The Clear Lake Murders
The three mustaches tackle a case from their home state of Texas, and believe me, this one will raise your eyebrows. When Rachael Koloroutis, Tiffany Rowell, Marcus Precella, and Adelbert Sanchez were...
27 Mar 20251h 53min
61 | Dharmesh Patel | Tesla Takes a Tumble
In this episode, the three mustaches investigate a family of four that mysteriously drove over a cliff in their Tesla. Was it a case of a malfunctioning self-driving car? Did the wife snap and force t...
20 Mar 20251h 39min
60 | Megan Parra | Slide Into The Crime Scene
The three mustaches come together once again to discuss the suspicious suicide of Megan Parra. What would drive a woman with a happy family and a bright future to take her own life? Did it have someth...
13 Mar 20251h 23min
59 | The Bever Familicide | The Kids Are Not Alright
The three mustaches discuss the disturbing case of the Bever family in Broken Arrow, OK. At around 11:30 p.m. on July 22, 2015, police were alerted to 709 Magnolia Court by a 911 phone call made by 1...
6 Mar 20252h 2min
58 | Colleen Stan | The Girl In The Box
*ALERT: THE EPISODE THAT WILL GET THIS SHOW CANCELLED* Longtime listeners have heard tales of the elusive “Girl In The Box” episode that the mustaches refer to in many episodes. Well here you go sic...
27 Feb 20251h 39min
57 | Sarah Buzzard | Me, My Girlfriend And My Husband's Boyfriend
The mustaches are joined by Rob "Hot Bob" Fox of Softcore History to discuss the 2015 murder of Ryan Zimmerman. On Jan. 5, 2016 the dismembered remains of Ryan Zimmerman were discovered near a lake ...
20 Feb 20252h 45min
