It's the Mystery for Me (A True Crime Podcast)

When Shilie Turner, 17, goes missing before a big track meet, it sends the whole town into a frenzy. The cops work every angle and then pursue an unexpected one: bringing in a psychic. This proves to be incredibly helpful and puts cops on the direct path to the killer… who turns out to be someone that had been right in front of their face all along. **Before we get into the Shilie Turner case, we provide an update in the Chioma Grey case [Episode 13] and talk about the case...

21 Sep 202146min

On May 8, 1981, Jamey Walker, 18, had just returned home from a date when she was kidnapped and held for ransom. Before the family could provide the requested amount of $75,000 to the kidnapper(s), Jamey was murdered. It would take 30+ years for "justice" to be served but even then... the ending is unlike anything anyone could have ever expected.For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/jamey-walker

14 Sep 202152min

Survelliance cameras show sophomore Chioma Gray, 15, getting into a car with her much older "boyfriend" -- if you can call him that -- Andrew Joshua Tefoya, 20. By 1:20PM, they've crossed the MX border and within days, her case has gone cold. What happened to Chioma Gray? For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/chioma

7 Sep 202140min

In June 2021, the clip of a murderer acting as his own counsel went viral -- specifically, for the over the top theatrics. In this episode, we put the spotlight on the victims of the heinous crime for which the murderer stood trial -- his longtime girlfriend and mother of his children, Kenyatta "Keke" Barron, his daughter, Jon'Niveya, and his son, Jon IV. For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/k...

24 Aug 202141min

Linda Robinson, 36, had just returned home after dropping her teenage daughter at a skating rink. She was babysitting her niece, 7, and nephew (~6 months) at the time and had just begun making dinner. Her niece, 7, fell asleep and woke up to an absolute horror: the sound of the firing alarm and her Aunt Linda dead on the floor. This whodunnit spans 23+ years and when the killer is finally revealed — it leaves everyone stumped. For a list of sources from today's episode and...

17 Aug 202142min

Chiquita Tate, 34, was a trailblazing criminal defense attorney. Even her adversaries in the courtroom could do nothing but praise her. Unfortunately, Chiquita’s personal life was a stark contrast from her reality. She constantly contemplated leaving her husband, who had a documented abusive streak. On February 19, 2009, Chiquita told her sister that she was done with her husband. That night, Chiquita, was murdered. National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-...

10 Aug 20211h 1min

Kanika Powell, 28, heard a knock on her door in August 2008. The person on the other side knew her name, but she didn't know them. They said they were FBI. Kanika was so rattled that she emailed her family and friends an account of the event. She also called the police and the FBI - and installed a new security system. Just a few days later, Kanika was murdered. Tune in as we analyze the intracacies of Kanika's case, which is still unsolved. For a list of ...

3 Aug 202138min

Mujey Dumbuya, 16, did something that many are hesitant to do: in November 2017, she reported her abuser to authorities and began to prepare to testify against him at his upcoming trial. Unfortunately, Mujey was never able to do that because in January 2018, she was murdered. Tune in as we weave our way through this *solved* case.For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes

27 Jul 202147min