It's the Mystery for Me (A True Crime Podcast)

On June 24, 2018, Aniya Mack, 24, left her home for a meeting regarding an upcoming performance at her church—Second Baptist Church in Kalamazoo, Michigan. Her boyfriend, Donnovan Lewis, was adamant that this was Aniya's last known location. It had been days since he and Aniya's family heard from Aniya. Now, detectives are working quickly to piece together what really happened to her, as clues start to unravel a secret life. Could this be the missing piece to finding Aniya? ...

11 Apr 202358min

On September 24, 1983, Sabrina Buie, 11, went to her friend’s house to drop off a bike. Her sister, Tenita, who was 4 years old at the time, notes that it was the last time she saw Sabrina alive. Detectives are eager to solve this case by any means necessary, but will this stance benefit Sabrina’s family or torpedo the case? For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/sabrina-buie Attorney Benjamin Crump's Instagram ...

4 Apr 20231h 17min

Cherice Ragins, 24, planned to spend the weekend with her boyfriend Travis like she had many times before. But when her mother didn’t hear from Cherice on the night of February 19, 2010, and the days that followed, she became extremely worried. It was not like Cherice to not check in with her mother, Clariese. When she later learns that Cherice did in fact spend the weekend with Travis at his parent’s house, she feels somewhat relieved. But that relief was short lived when Travis could not ac...

29 Mar 20231h 5min

In the summer of 2013, Danielle Locklear moved to North Carolina to live with her grandparents and her aunt, while her mom dealt with a painful divorce. Danielle was excited to have a distraction from that -- and in came in the form of a new love interest: Je'Michael. It wouldn’t take long for Danielle, 15, to get acclimated to North Carolina —she got straight A’s and made lots of friends. All was going well until one night in 2014 when Danielle left her house to return a book to...

21 Mar 20231h 19min

Ayesha Turner was a young mother of two—a 5-year-old and 12-year-old. Ayesha had graduated Everest College as a medical assistant and was starting to get her life in order. But on the evening of October 5, 2012, Ayesha would leave the home she shared with her mother and kids and never return. Ayesha’s mother stated that this was out of character for her daughter and reported her missing immediately. The weeks that followed would bring forth a series of third-party statements sending det...

7 Mar 202358min

In 2014, Felecia Williams was just a 9-year-old in the third grade. Like most children her age, Felecia was inquisitive yet naive. The second youngest of six girls, Felecia developed a close relationship with her neighbor and family friend, Eboni Wiley. But this close bond would be forever broken by the events that transpired on May 16, 2014. Felecia was missing and Eboni could not account for the child's whereabouts, leaving Felecia's family and investigators baffled. So, did Eboni possibly ...

14 Feb 20231h 4min

In Part 1, we leave off with the "conclusion" of Marshall Jr.'s case. However, at that point in time (1996), Michelle Soto's case was still unsolved. In Part 2, we continue to unravel this story, introduce Deborah and try to make sense of the "pattern" between the murders. For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/michellesotoOur Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

8 Feb 202332min

Michelle Soto is a devoted mother and beloved teacher. Her murder in the Summer of 1995 leaves the community in shock. A local reporter, Renee Ferguson, is tapped to look into her case and soon discovers that there may be a common link in Michelle’s case and the cases of other people, like Marshall Jr. Looking into this case starts to unravel something bigger than Renee could imagine. In Part 1, law enforcement is confronted with Renee’s findings. But will they i...

7 Feb 202351min