406: The Girl on the Milk Carton
Five days before Christmas 1984, 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews went missing from her own living room in the small town of Greeley, Colo. In an attempt to find her, Jonelle was given the tragic distinct...
10 Dec 20241h 12min
405: Web of Death: California Dreaming
Samson Cree National Violet Soosay has spent her life on a quest to find her missing Aunt Shirley. Meanwhile, researchers from the DNA Doe Project are hunting for the identity of a woman murdered in C...
5 Dec 202445min
404: Family Secrets: The Disappearance of Alissa Turney
Viral sensation and fierce victim advocate Sarah Turney examines her tumultuous childhood to reconstruct the truth about her suspicions that her dad killed her sister Alissa. LOOKING FOR MORE TCO? O...
3 Dec 20241h 26min
BIG ANNOUNCEMENT! CHECK THIS OUT!
FAM! Patrick here! I'm headed back out on tour WITH A BRAND NEW SHOW! It's a storytelling evening that turns into a party where I get to meet all of you an you all get to meet fellow TCO Fam in your a...
2 Dec 20242min
403: Worst Roommate Ever: My BFF Tried To Kill Me
Rachel and Jamie were longtime best friends and roommates. But as Janie's obsession with raising Rachel's young son grew, so did her killer instincts. FAM! OUR MERCH STORE IS NOW LIVE FOR EVEYRONE! ...
26 Nov 20241h 9min
402: Andreen McDonald: A Millionaire Vanishes (From 48 Hours)
On March 1, 2019, an uber-successful young businesswoman named Andreen McDonald was reported missing by her family and friends. The disappearance didn't make any sense. She had a thriving business, a ...
21 Nov 202450min
401: Sweet Bobby: My Catfish Nightmare
Gird your loins for one of the most elaborate and sophisticated--AND TRULY SHOCKING--scams you'll ever hear. Kirat, a successful marketing executive and radio personality, is contacted online by a man...
19 Nov 20241h 8min
Ashley Madison: Sex, Lies, & Scandal (from Patreon)
GIRD YOUR LOINS FAM, BECAUSE HOLY MOLY DO WE HAVE SH*T TO SAY! In the early 2000s some man had what he thought was a great idea: to create a website for people who want to have affairs, but not leave ...
17 Nov 202456min
