#198 - How Decisions Get Written, with Justice Peter Edelmann

#198 - How Decisions Get Written, with Justice Peter Edelmann

In this audio-only reunion episode, former Borderlines Podcast host Peter Edelman joins to discuss life on the British Columbia Court of Appeal.


Topics discussed include how decisions get made and written, the role of counsel in shaping outcomes, pressures facing Canada’s judicial review system, judicial collegiality and dissenting reasons, immigration backlogs, adversarial justice, and the emotional weight of judging.


2:16 – Learning curve: trial court vs appellate court

6:31 – Does good lawyering really matter in judicial review?

19:28 – Precision in judgments & unintended interpretations

23:40 – Dissents, concurrences & shaping the law

27:17 – Should judges clarify controversial rulings later?

33:06 – Rethinking adversarial justice

49:06 – Is it easier to judge or be judged?

55:07 – Does being a judge change personal decision-making?


https://youtu.be/nJ8kM4zJLdU?si=5L4nmGJz5eaKbXAm

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Avsnitt(220)

#76 - Differential Treatment as a Breach of Procedural Fairness, with Pantea Jafari

#76 - Differential Treatment as a Breach of Procedural Fairness, with Pantea Jafari

Pantea Jafari is lead counsel at Jafari Law, which she opened in 2012. In 2022 Pantea won a successful group litigation for over 100 Iranian applicants whose applications were refused under the Self-E...

22 Sep 20221h 2min

#75 - Working at DOJ vs. Private Practice, with Jennifer Dagsvik, Nalini Reddy, and Rafeena Rashid

#75 - Working at DOJ vs. Private Practice, with Jennifer Dagsvik, Nalini Reddy, and Rafeena Rashid

Three former counsel at the Department of Justice discuss what practicing at the DOJ is like vs. private practice. Jennifer Dagsvik worked as Legal Counsel at the Department of Justice from 2007 – 201...

24 Aug 20221h 38min

#74 - Practicing High Net Worth Asian Immigration to Canada in the 1980s, with Peter Scarrow

#74 - Practicing High Net Worth Asian Immigration to Canada in the 1980s, with Peter Scarrow

Peter Scarrow practiced Canadian immigration law from 1981 - 1991, opening the Taiwanese representative office for a prominent Vancouver law firm. We discuss what practicing high net worth immigration...

8 Aug 20221h 39min

#73 - From an Investor Immigrant Practice to Canadian Human Rights Tribunal Chair, with David Thomas

#73 - From an Investor Immigrant Practice to Canadian Human Rights Tribunal Chair, with David Thomas

David Thomas practiced immigration law from 1987 - 2014, when he was appointed Chairperson of the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. During his career he developed a large investor clientele from South ...

15 Juli 20221h 6min

#72 - Misrepresentation

#72 - Misrepresentation

A discussion of misrepresentation, including its application, consequences, the innocent mistake defense, failing to disclose past visa refusals, the difference between insufficient evidence and misre...

29 Juni 20221h

#71 - Extending Supervisas to Five Years, with Kyle Seeback, MP

#71 - Extending Supervisas to Five Years, with Kyle Seeback, MP

Kyle Seeback is the Member of Parliament for Dufferin - Caledon. He is the author of Bill C-242, the Reuniting Families Act.Bill C-242 would allow a parent or grandparent who applies for a temporary ...

17 Juni 202237min

#70 - The Importance of Compassion, with David Langlands, a 37-year Officer at CBSA

#70 - The Importance of Compassion, with David Langlands, a 37-year Officer at CBSA

David Langlands is a recently retired 37-year officer of the Canada Border Services Agency. He worked at land, sea, air and even mail points of entry.We discuss his career, interacting with refugee c...

13 Apr 20221h 15min

#69 - COVID-19 as an H&C Factor, Mandamus and FSW vs. CEC Priorities, with Raj Sharma

#69 - COVID-19 as an H&C Factor, Mandamus and FSW vs. CEC Priorities, with Raj Sharma

A discussion about the Federal Court of Canada decision in Mohammad v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2022 FC 1, how being a COVID-19 front-line worker is considered in the H&C context, mandamu...

16 Feb 202257min

Populärt inom Politik & nyheter

aftonbladet-krim
svenska-fall
p3-krim
rss-krimstad
flashback-forever
spar
rss-sanning-konsekvens
rss-vad-fan-hande
aftonbladet-daily
motiv
rss-krimreportrarna
politiken
rss-klubbland-en-podd-mest-om-frolunda
grans
rss-flodet
rss-aftonbladet-krim
olyckan-inifran
krimmagasinet
rss-frandfors-horna
dagens-eko