Episode 22: Headbutt a Hooker | The Abduction of Colleen Stan

Did you miss us and have withdrawals!? Trust when we say, us too. But here we are, and most importantly here is part one of John Wayne Gacy. In this episode Katie & Papa Bear go into the specific mold...

20 Jan 20231h 13min

It's a Yule Tide Christmas horror over here! Ole Saint Nick isn't the only tradition celebrated around Christmas time, Creeps. On this episode Katie & Papa Bear look into the not so holly jolly side o...

20 Dec 202249min

It's here! Finally! Get ready creeps! This episode is absolutely bonkers as Katie & Nate dove headfirst into the horrifying world of sleep paralysis. As they went deeper and deeper into the phases of ...

15 Dec 20221h 11min

Papa Bear is back!!! And the creeps are bringing all the weirdness on this one! With time way over due for a cryptid episode, Katie & Nate cracked open the oddity that is, The Chupacabra. With a dash ...

5 Dec 202259min

Welcome to the new mini series "Reddit Reads" where the head creeps pick a topic and then search through reddit and creepypasta for some of the best of the best (or at least good lookin) stories out ...

28 Nov 202231min

Well, looky who's back on schedule! Hey Creeps! Katie is at it again, and with a special sub in co-host Mama Jerri, as they dig into part two of Matthew Hoffman a.k.a. The Leaf Killer. In this conclus...

28 Nov 20221h 43min

Matthew Hoffman was the epitome of a Grade A Creep. He seemed like the normal stubborn kid during childhood, with an added dash of Dendrophilia or "love of trees" added to the mix. But when he was bor...

14 Nov 20221h 8min

Its time for a lighthearted episode Creeps! And boy did Katie & Nate deliver on this one. After the last few episodes being such heavy ones it was time for a break and what better topic than the origi...

13 Okt 202251min