The Perils of 'Long Term Sick Limbo' - How HR Missteps Can Lead to Massive Liabilities

Judith Fiddler opens this episode by delving into a perplexing HR challenge she calls "long-term sick limbo." This refers to situations where an employee has been out on extended sick leave, often for work-related stress, and the employer reaches a point where they feel they can no longer accommodate the prolonged absence. However, the employee is reluctant to return, fearing the underlying issues that led to their sickness have not been resolved.

Fiddler explains that this standoff frequently occurs when employers fail to proactively engage with the employee during their leave. Rather than maintaining regular contact and exploring ways to facilitate their safe return, companies often "file away" the issue, waiting passively for sick notes to arrive. This reactive approach, Fiddler asserts, is a recipe for the sort of "Mexican standoff" that ultimately ensues.

Fiddler then walks through a real-life case study that illustrates the pitfalls. The employee, a senior compliance manager, had raised a grievance prior to her sick leave, but the employer ignored it. When the occupational health assessment ultimately confirmed the employee's claims of bullying and work-related stress, the employer responded poorly - rejecting the findings, threatening disciplinary action, and refusing to engage in the recommended discussions to rebuild trust.

This disastrous handling, Fiddler explains, transformed what could have been a straightforward return-to-work process into a potential constructive dismissal claim worth an estimated £80,000 to £100,000. The crux of the issue, she emphasizes, is the mindset and decision-making of the HR team. Rather than pursuing a supportive, problem-solving approach, they opted for the "nastier" route of manufactured misconduct allegations.

Fiddler's overarching message is a call for HR professionals to be acutely aware of the consequences their actions can have. In the high-stakes world of long-term sickness cases, the choices between a "nice," supportive response versus a more confrontational one can make all the difference. She cautions that even when HR believes they are on safe ground, their actions can "come back to haunt" them in the form of substantial legal liabilities.

Ultimately, Fiddler underscores the paramount importance of HR's mindset and decision-making when navigating these sensitive situations. By fostering an accountable, solution-focused approach, they can help resolve "long-term sick limbo" scenarios constructively. However, a victim mentality or overly aggressive tactics can rapidly transform a manageable issue into a costly disaster.

🔍 Stay informed with the latest HR processes, rules, and best practices.

📚 Learn from real-life tribunal cases with practical lessons.

💬 Receive unlimited expert advice from industry professionals.

💼 Transform your career and mindset.

🌐 www.hrinrehab.com