Episode 298: 90s Heartthrobs or Cult Leaders? Part 2

Lions and Tigers and Evangelical Pastors ... Oh My!; A Venetian Lesson; Behind the Eye Graffiti Electric Box: A South African Mystery; Who Stitched Me Up?; The Scarecrow in My Closet; and Werewolf or ...

6 Juli 20241h 6min

Their faces graced the cover of teen magazines, and the dreamy roles they played in the 1990s and 2000s got the hearts of their young fans pumping. But now, not one but two former ‘90s heartthrobs hav...

3 Juli 20241h 26min

My Mom Took AP Classes with a Family Annihilator; Carjacking/Kidnapping/Drunk Guy Situation; Revenge Is a Dish Best Self-Served Cold; The 666 Elm St Ghost Boy; I Think I Saw a Sasquatch? Or It Saw Mor...

28 Juni 20241h 12min

With an outpouring of support, Mica’s family began their quest for justice. Disappointed with law enforcement, they eventually turned to the media. Meanwhile, sworn statements from JP's ex-wife and Mi...

26 Juni 20242h

My Mom Was Stalked by A Serial Killer; Freaky Twintuition; A Possible Third Man Phenomenon; "Help" Isn't Always Helpful: A Wheelchair Users Story; My Photo of a Ghost at the Haunted Baker Hotel; and A...

21 Juni 20241h 5min

A pastor’s nonchalant announcement of his wife’s death at a Sunday service garnered national media attention. As more details of his life became public, a harrowing picture emerged of what his now-dec...

19 Juni 20241h 34min

"I Killed Him"; I Survived a Campus Christian Cult; The Milkman of East Dallas; Dream Phone Ouija Dupe; Who IS My Doppelganger?; and Hamburglar's Confession Click here to submit your odd but true sto...

14 Juni 202459min

In late April, a charismatic pastor from South Carolina made a sudden announcement at the end of his sermon: his wife was dead. The internet began questioning the strange delivery, and her loved ones ...

12 Juni 20241h 30min