Ep 152: Why Relying on Data Can Cause More Harm Than Good

Ep 152: Why Relying on Data Can Cause More Harm Than Good

Cathy O’Neil is a mathematician who has worked as a professor, hedge-fund analyst and data scientist. Cathy founded ORCAA, an algorithmic auditing company, and is the author of Weapons of Math Destruction.

Cathy says she was always a math nerd. She loves the beauty of mathematics, and says it is almost an art – the cleanliness of it. One of her favorite things is that math is the same no matter what country you go to. She also had had an interest in the business world, which led her from academia to work as a hedge fund quantitative analyst.

Big Data is both a technical and marketing term. The technical term depends on the technology you are using. Big data used to mean that it was more data than you could fit on your computer – now it means more that you can perform in a simple way – that it needs to be put it into another form before it can be used.

The marketing term, ‘big data’ is misleading. However, it represents the belief that you can collect data for one thing but then the same data can be used for another purpose. “It is a technology that allows us to collect seemly innocuous data and use it for another purpose.”

One profession in which O’Neil has at looked at the use of big data and algorithms in detail – and discusses in her book – is teaching and their evaluations. She says there were teacher evaluation algorithms originally designed to eliminate the achievement gap between ‘rich kids and poor kids’. Eventually, a new system was devised entitled, ‘value added teacher model’.

The idea of this new system intended to offset the previous way of looking at assessing teachers - where they solely looked at the teacher’s students’ final test scores.

The ‘value added score’ system holds teachers accountable for the difference between students’ final score and what they were expected to achieve/receive.

O’Neil says that this method ‘sounds good’ and seems to ‘make sense’. However, with only 25 (or so) students in one teacher’s classroom, there is not enough data. Additionally, both the expected and actual scores have a lot of uncertainty around each of them. So this final number ‘ends up not much better than a random number’. With that, there is not enough credible data to base important decisions such as terminating a teacher’s job.

One of O’Neil’s main points in today’s discussion is that every algorithm is subjective. Whether it is used to evaluate teachers, hire or fire employees in a financial organization - people should know that they have the right to ask the algorithm explained to them. The 14th Amendment provides them ‘due process’ to ask why they are terminated, not promoted, etc. - other than just alluding to a algorithm result.

What you will learn in this episode:

  • What is ‘weaponized math’?
  • How is the internet building a new kind of ‘class’?
  • What are the 2 definitions of ‘big data’?
  • The potential bias found in the use of algorithms in teacher evaluations, hiring practices, firing

Avsnitt(1053)

Sparks: Build The Future of Work With The World’s Top CHROs

Sparks: Build The Future of Work With The World’s Top CHROs

Future of Work Leaders is a NEW community of the world’s top CHROs who are shaping the future of work and employee experience. Other communities focus purely on traditional HR, are VERY expensive, members are constantly being sold to, and there’s far more fluff than value. Future of Work Leaders is affordable for any CHRO, there’s no selling, no speeches, and no fluff. It’s purely focused on strategy, insight, and connections with world leading CHROs who are shaping the future of work and employee experience. Join 40 members including CHROs from LEGO, Johnson & Johnson, Dow, Tractor Supply, Northrop Grumman, and Neiman Marcus. Check out FutureOfWorkLeaders.com to learn more and request an invite.   ________________ Start your day with the world’s top leaders by joining thousands of others at Great Leadership on Substack. Just enter your email: ⁠⁠https://greatleadership.substack.com/

14 Feb 14min

Sahil Bloom on Why Success Isn’t Just About Money

Sahil Bloom on Why Success Isn’t Just About Money

Are you chasing the wrong kind of wealth? We all chase success, but too often, it’s tied to money, fame, or career milestones. Sahil Bloom, author of The Five Types of Wealth and creator of the Curiosity Chronicle newsletter, believes that true wealth lies in a balance of time, relationships, health, mental clarity, and financial stability. In today’s episode, Sahil introduces a fresh way to think about success by focusing on these five types of wealth. We explore how to connect your work to your purpose, overcome the trap of overthinking, and use simple frameworks to build deeper connections and more meaningful progress. We’ll unpack Sahil’s transformative insights, including why chasing money without purpose leads to burnout, how to build "social wealth" to combat the loneliness epidemic, the power of questioning cultural norms to find your identity, and how even small actions can create massive compounding effects in life.   ________________ Start your day with the world’s top leaders by joining thousands of others at Great Leadership on Substack. Just enter your email: ⁠⁠https://greatleadership.substack.com/

10 Feb 51min

Sparks: Are Today’s Leaders Too Afraid? How to Lead With Confidence, Courage, and Respect

Sparks: Are Today’s Leaders Too Afraid? How to Lead With Confidence, Courage, and Respect

Are today’s leaders too afraid to lead? In today's Leadership Spark, we explore the challenges of leadership today, from balancing psychological safety with accountability to being honest about workplace expectations. We discuss how over-coddling employees and focusing too much on feelings can backfire, and why it’s important for leaders to set clear standards while fostering respect and responsibility.   ________________ Start your day with the world’s top leaders by joining thousands of others at Great Leadership on Substack. Just enter your email: ⁠⁠https://greatleadership.substack.com/

7 Feb 4min

Three Leadership Skills to Thrive in the Future of Work

Three Leadership Skills to Thrive in the Future of Work

The secret to better leadership in the future of work isn't knowing everything, but mastering the right things. This episode brings together three leadership visionaries—Diego Barreto, CEO of iFood; Jeff Kindler, former CEO of Pfizer; and Frederic Laloux, author of Reinventing Organizations—to share the tools you need to lead smarter in the new world of work. You'll learn why mastering one skill at a time, encouraging constructive disagreement, and embracing self-management are the keys to navigating uncertainty, driving better decisions, and building agile teams.   ________________ Start your day with the world’s top leaders by joining thousands of others at Great Leadership on Substack. Just enter your email: ⁠⁠https://greatleadership.substack.com/

3 Feb 55min

Sparks: Employee Engagement Is Not a Long-Term Workplace Solution

Sparks: Employee Engagement Is Not a Long-Term Workplace Solution

Most employees start their journey excited and motivated, but that enthusiasm often fades when organizations rely on perks like yoga or free food to boost engagement. These quick fixes don’t address deeper needs. In today's Leadership Spark, we dig into the critical difference between employee engagement and employee experience, showing how leading companies shift from superficial perks to meaningful workplace transformation. Learn why only 6% of organizations excel in creating environments where employees thrive—and how your company can join them.   ________________ Start your day with the world’s top leaders by joining thousands of others at Great Leadership on Substack. Just enter your email: ⁠⁠https://greatleadership.substack.com/

30 Jan 8min

Strategies For Effective Mentor and Mentee Relationships At Work

Strategies For Effective Mentor and Mentee Relationships At Work

Mentorship is often misunderstood. Many mentees expect their mentors to drive the relationship or solve their problems. But Amy Salcido, President of Kyndryl U.S., shows us a different take on how to do mentorship right. In today’s episode, Amy shares her unique insights from leading a team of 16,000 employees in one of the world’s largest IT infrastructure companies. Amy unpacks the lessons she learned at IBM, where mentorship was pivotal in her rise to executive leadership. She explains why mentorship fails without proactive mentees taking responsibility for their own growth, how authenticity accelerates leadership success, and why the best mentors don’t give you answers—they guide you to find them yourself. We also tackle the surprising benefits of focusing on passions instead of job titles and how to structure effective mentor-mentee relationships in any organization.   ________________ Start your day with the world’s top leaders by joining thousands of others at Great Leadership on Substack. Just enter your email: ⁠⁠https://greatleadership.substack.com/

27 Jan 1h 1min

Sparks: The Vulnerability Wheel and How Vulnerability Can Be Used For and Against Your Favor

Sparks: The Vulnerability Wheel and How Vulnerability Can Be Used For and Against Your Favor

Have you ever wondered if vulnerability could backfire? Leaders often face tough decisions about when and how to be open, and the stakes are high when trust is involved. In today's Leadership Spark, we explore a powerful story about a CEO who learned hard lessons about vulnerability after it was used against her early in her career. You'll hear insights on navigating trust, why vulnerability is essential for leadership, and how self-compassion can be your safety net when things go wrong. This episode also introduces the "Vulnerability Wheel" framework to help leaders use vulnerability effectively.   ________________ Start your day with the world’s top leaders by joining thousands of others at Great Leadership on Substack. Just enter your email: ⁠⁠https://greatleadership.substack.com/

24 Jan 5min

How Lumen CEO Kate Johnson Changed the Culture of a Billion-Dollar Company From Playing Not to Lose to Playing to Win

How Lumen CEO Kate Johnson Changed the Culture of a Billion-Dollar Company From Playing Not to Lose to Playing to Win

Turning around a struggling company isn’t for the faint of heart, but Kate Johnson, CEO of Lumen Technologies, is proving it can be done—and done well. Leading 30,000 employees and steering billions in revenue, Kate is tackling one of the toughest challenges in business: shifting a telecom giant from “playing not to lose” to “playing to win.” In this episode, Kate opens her fresh and fearless playbook on what it really takes to transform a culture: it starts with clarifying your mission and getting everyone aligned. She shares bold, practical strategies like fostering trust, teaching resilience, and encouraging courageous conversations that push teams forward, not sideways. We’ll also unpack why most leaders fail at culture change (and it’s not for lack of trying), how to break silos by getting close to the action, and the non-negotiables for any leader’s first 100 days. If you’re ready to rethink what it means to lead and create a culture that wins, you don’t want to miss this one.  ________________ Start your day with the world’s top leaders by joining thousands of others at Great Leadership on Substack. Just enter your email: ⁠⁠https://greatleadership.substack.com/

20 Jan 1h

Populärt inom Business & ekonomi

framgangspodden
varvet
badfluence
svd-ledarredaktionen
rss-borsens-finest
uppgang-och-fall
avanzapodden
lastbilspodden
rss-dagen-med-di
fill-or-kill
affarsvarlden
rss-kort-lang-analyspodden-fran-di
borsmorgon
rikatillsammans-om-privatekonomi-rikedom-i-livet
tabberaset
kapitalet-en-podd-om-ekonomi
dynastin
market-makers
borslunch-2
rss-inga-dumma-fragor-om-pengar