Vigilante | The Gary Plauche Story

In this episode of Unspeakable we unravel a haunting true crime story that will send shivers down your spine. KJ guides you through a disturbing case that challenges our understanding of human depravity, exploring crimes that defy comprehension and delve into the darkest recesses of the human psyche. We kick off our journey in 1980 with the unsettling story of John White, a seemingly ordinary young man whose life takes a dark and sinister turn when he becomes embroiled in a brutal attack on a teenage girl. What initially seems like a case of self-defense soon unravels into a twisted tale of frenzied violence and calculated malevolence, showcased through the chilling testimony of the victim, Teresa Etherton. As we peel back the layers of this case, we uncover the harrowing insights into John's troubled past, his disturbing behavior, and the eerie contrast between his outward persona and the darkness that lurks within. Through meticulous research, we explore the intricate psychological nuances at play during the attack, shedding light on the perplexing motivations behind such incomprehensible acts of brutality. We witness John's descent into further atrocities, from a chilling confession about the death of his lover, Vicki Sue, to the disturbing trail of evidence that implicates him in her murder. Despite a veneer of rehabilitation during his time in prison and his subsequent role as a pastor, lingering doubts persist about the sincerity of his transformation and the complexities of human nature in the face of unfathomable evil. The heart-wrenching saga of Rebecca Gay, her vibrant personality, and the tragic events that befall her at the hands of John White will leave you reeling.Timestamps0:06:09 John White: The Troubled Past0:09:55 John's Early Adulthood0:11:22 Teresa's Visit and Incident0:14:12 Trial Revelations0:18:00 Euphoria and Dysphoric Mania0:22:02 Appeal and Release0:23:14 Insanity Defense in the 1980s0:26:15 John's Disrespect for Women0:29:28 Affair with Vicki Sue0:29:37 Vicki Sue's Disappearance0:32:30 The Discovery of Vicki Sue's Body0:42:43 Concerns About John's Past0:47:10 The Disappearance of Rebecca0:51:23 20 Hours of Uncertainty1:00:19 John White's Arrest and Sentencing

20 Mars 20241h 4min

In this Part 2 of "The Welfare Check" Kelly delves deeper into the chilling true crime story of the Guy family murders, exploring the gruesome details of the crime scene and the emotional impact on those connected to the victims. Michelle Tyler's struggle to come to terms with the loss of her parents and the revelations surrounding her brother, Joel Jr., add layers to the complex narrative. The investigation exposes the meticulous planning and shocking motives behind the heinous acts, culminating in a trial that delivers justice but leaves a community shattered by unspeakable evil.Timestamps0:02:50 Part Two: The Guy Couple Killings Investigation Begins 0:08:41 The Gruesome Scene Unfolds0:12:29 The Killer's Methodical Actions0:16:27 Breaking the Heartbreaking News0:19:55 A Daughter's Desperate Request 0:22:22 Advocating for Victims' Rights0:24:56 Michelle's Alarming Discoveries0:26:26 The Clue in Joel Jr.'s Actions0:30:20 Unforeseen Crime Scene0:30:47 Questionable Story Unveiled 0:37:03 Disturbing Plans Revealed0:40:05 Sinister Document Unearthed0:51:41 Arrest and Revelation0:54:25 Crucial Financial Evidence Uncovered0:56:24 Heartfelt Family Tributes0:59:14 Guilty Verdict and Sentencing

13 Mars 20241h 2min

In this episode of "Unspeakable," Kelly recounts the story of a welfare check that turned into a nightmare. Lisa and Joel Guy Sr. vanished under mysterious circumstances, sparking concerns due to their son Joel Jr.'s strange behavior. Police discovered a chilling scene in the family home - from an overpowering chemical odor to gruesome evidence of violence, including severed body parts in containers. The investigation into this horrific crime delves into the motives and suspects behind the heinous murders, as the community grapples with the unsettling reality of such evil acts. Tune in for the next episode as the pieces of this chilling puzzle slowly come together.Timestamps:0:02:51 Unexpected Visitor0:05:23 A Family's Dream0:14:59 Unemployed at 280:18:03 Concerning Absences 0:21:50 Mysterious Signs0:27:46 Searching for Answers 0:33:15 Chilling Discovery0:39:16 Unthinkable Outcome

6 Mars 202440min

Unspeakable Live 2 took place at the Southeastern Livingston Center, showcasing Kelly's captivating storytelling in a live setting. The auditorium provided a perfect backdrop for the event, creating an immersive experience for the audience.With an initial date quickly selling out, an additional date was added to accommodate the overwhelming demand, a testament to the podcast's growing popularity. The live event featured engaging content on the notorious serial killer Derek Todd Lee, shedding light on the victims and their stories. The atmosphere was electric, with a sold-out crowd, food trucks serving delicious fare, and unique unspeakable swag for attendees to cherish.Kelly's dynamic presentation style kept the audience engrossed, with visuals complementing her narrative without feeling didactic. The event's intermission allowed for a breather, ensuring everyone could fully absorb the weight of the chilling tale being shared. A poignant moment occurred when a survivor of Derek Todd Lee's attacks, a woman from Zachary, Louisiana, stood up during the event, highlighting the resilience and courage of those impacted by such heinous crimes.Kelly's focus on honoring the victims was evident throughout, earning her a well-deserved standing ovation for her empathetic storytelling. The event concluded on a high note, with attendees lining up to meet Kelly, get personalized swag, and share moments with the team behind the podcast. Future plans include a docu-series on Derek Todd Lee announced at the event, which promises a deeply immersive experience with a cinematic touch, set to captivate audiences in a new way. Check out Factor!This holiday season, you might be looking for nutritious, convenient meals to keep you energized on jam-packed days. Factor, America’s #1 Ready-To-Eat Meal Delivery Service, can help you fuel up fast for breakfast, lunch, and dinner with chef-prepared, dietitian-approved ready-to-eat meals delivered straight to your door. You’ll save time, eat well, and stay on track with your healthy lifestyle while tackling all your holiday to- dos.Click HERE for 50% off by using the code unspeakable50

28 Feb 202427min

In this episode, Kelly recounts the chilling story of Amy St. Laurent, a young woman who vanished in 2001 after a night out. Amy's determination for a fulfilling life was evident until her abrupt disappearance following a night spent with Eric Rubright in Portland, post her breakup with boyfriend Richard. Eric's dubious actions and testimony caught police attention, prompting Jeffrey Gorman, another person present that evening, to disclose crucial details under peer influence. Gorman corroborated Eric's version of events, intensifying the search for Amy despite inconclusive polygraph results, leaving her family in anguish.Kelly covers the unsettling events surrounding Amy's vanishing, implicating Russ - who offered Amy a ride from a discomforting party - as a prime suspect. Russ's evasive demeanor, refusal of a polygraph, and inconsistencies in his roommates' statements unveiled a harrowing narrative involving assault, drugging, and a fatal shooting. Russ's erratic behavior, confession to his mother, subsequent arrest, and a 60-year prison sentence ultimately served justice, despite his mother's efforts to retract her statement, emphasizing the tragic injustice Amy endured.Timestamps:0:03:41 Amy's High School and College Dreams0:06:46 Amy's Night Out in 20010:10:06 Eric Rubright's Confusion and Concern0:17:56 Police Press Conference and Investigation0:20:50 Tip Line and Jeffrey "Russ" Gorman's Call0:23:32 Uncomfortable Departure0:24:37 Polygraph Decline0:26:51 Suspicious Details0:28:32 Applying Pressure0:30:20 Suspicious Detail0:32:16 Search Initiates0:35:20 Tool Borrowing0:37:33 Cadaver Dog Discovery0:43:03 Disturbing Confession0:46:38 Compelled Testimony 0:48:37 Sentencing ReactionCheck out Factor! This holiday season, you might be looking for nutritious, convenient meals to keep you energized on jam-packed days. Factor, America’s #1 Ready-To-Eat Meal Delivery Service, can help you fuel up fast for breakfast, lunch, and dinner with chef-prepared, dietitian-approved ready-to-eat meals delivered straight to your door. You’ll save time, eat well, and stay on track with your healthy lifestyle while tackling all your holiday to- dos.Click HERE for 50% off by using the code unspeakable50

21 Feb 202451min

In this episode of Unspeakable, kelly completes her look into the shocking case of Vincent and Elizabeth Marinello in Louisiana.Liz's decision to divorce Vince leads to tragedy when she is shot outside her therapy session. Despite Vince's alibi, a suspicious figure near the crime scene points to a planned hit.

14 Feb 202442min

In this episode of Unspeakable, we delve into the shocking case of Vincent and Elizabeth Marinello in Louisiana.Liz's decision to divorce Vince leads to tragedy when she is shot outside her therapy session. Despite Vince's alibi, a suspicious figure near the crime scene points to a planned hit. 0:09:45 A Whirlwind Romance with an Age Gap0:13:51 Hurricane Katrina Devastates New Orleans0:17:02 Liz Marinello Files for Divorce from Vince0:22:53 Liz's Hope for an Annulment and Hiring an Attorney0:23:37 Vince's Narcissism: A Struggle for Truth and Communication0:24:40 Fragile Masculinity and Ego Shattered0:26:55 A Life Cut Short by Tragic Gunfire0:27:29 A Disturbing Encounter: Liz's Mysterious Attacker0:29:19 A Calculated Escape: The Elusive Assailant0:29:40 Liz's survival and initial medical assessment0:31:19 Personal experience with Glasgow Coma Score0:36:31 Liz's tragic death and investigation begins

7 Feb 202441min

In this episode, Kelly tells the story of a robbery turns deadly when a hate crime is exposed. An intense investigation begins in an effort to bring justice to the victims and prevent future incidents of violence.Timestamps:0:02:39 Introduction to the Case of Robert Schaefer0:09:18 The discussion turns to plans of robbing people0:13:26 Planning the Robbery and Gathering Weapons0:15:38 Premeditation and Hate Crime Motive0:20:25 Self-Hatred and Overcompensating: A Possible Motive0:27:39 The interaction and trust-building with the attackers0:32:14 The Suspicious Journey Begins at Sunoco Gas Station0:36:42 The Men's Fate Sealed at the Dead End Driveway0:41:15 Desperation Mounts as they Encounter a Stop Sign0:45:52 Brutal Execution: Denny's Tragic Fate0:48:19 Planning the Disposal of the Car and Evidence0:55:03 Robert's suspicious behavior and confession to shooting two people0:57:44 Robert's plan to turn himself in and manipulate his brother-in-law

31 Jan 20241h 1min