Episode 368: What Really Happened to Walter Collins??

On December 4, 1997, four members of the Daniels family were brutally shot and killed inside their home in the tiny town of Santa Claus, Georgia. The killer was Jerry Scott Heidler, then a 20-year-old...

29 Dec 202546min

Beauty queen, model, and actress Tammy Lynn Leppert was 18 years old when she mysteriously disappeared from Cocoa Beach, Florida in 1983. Tammy had been paranoid before her disappearance, scarred from...

18 Dec 202540min

Susan Diane Wolff Cappel was a 19‑year‑old woman from Newcomerstown, Ohio, who mysteriously disappeared on March 16, 1982. She was last seen leaving her job at the local IGA grocery store, where witne...

15 Dec 202544min

In July 1997, Michelle Moore-Bosko was murdered in the home she shared with her husband, US Navy sailor Billy Bosko. Investigators zeroed in on a suspect quickly, and despite coerced confessions and a...

11 Dec 20251h 2min

In this installment of listener stories, we’re bringing you a mix of heartfelt tales and just the right touch of creepiness. From moving accounts of loved ones from beyond to eerie encounters that wil...

8 Dec 202553min

Doris Spillers Worrell had a huge heart. The churchgoing mother of three loved to help others, and that’s exactly what she was doing when she welcomed 15 year old Paola Yarberry into her home. But whe...

4 Dec 202536min

Ashlea Aldrich, a 29-year-old mother from the Omaha Tribe of Nebraska, was found deceased in a field on the reservation in January 2020, with her death officially ruled an accident caused by hypotherm...

1 Dec 202532min

Olivia Lone Bear was last seen in New Town, North Dakota in October 2017 before she disappeared. The mother of 5 was found several months later, strapped into the passenger seat of the truck she was d...

27 Nov 202543min