S1 Ep5: Something's Watching
Tonight we delve into the chilling experiences of a seasoned hunter in the same eerie region of central Pennsylvania a former guest of our main show encountered something unexplained. Jordan recounts ...
26 Nov 202418min
The Ghost Ship Carroll A. Deering
In 1921, a five-masted schooner emerged from the mists off North Carolina's treacherous coast - a floating tomb devoid of life. Eleven souls had vanished without a trace, leaving behind an eerie table...
24 Nov 20242h 19min
S1 Ep4: Deployed Trickster
Tonight we dive into a chilling tale from a former member of the 75th Ranger Regiment, who had mysterious encounters with a face-pressing entity in their deployment tent. This story shows how paranorm...
19 Nov 202410min
S1 Ep3: It's Just Martin
In this episode, Scott and Forrest share a captivating story from a listener named Meagan about her family's experience with a friendly spirit named Martin. Since the late sixties, Meagan's family has...
12 Nov 202418min
The Lake Worth Monster with Lyle Blackburn
On the night of July 10, 1969, John Reichart was fishing near Greer Island on the shores of Lake Worth, about ten miles from Fort Worth, Texas, while his wife Linda sat in their car reading a book. M...
10 Nov 20241h 58min
S1 Ep2: Black-Eyed Kids and Bad Luck
In this episode, Scott and Forrest tackle a creepy listener story about Black Eyed Kids that took place during the height of the pandemic. The story follows a woman who encounters a strange boy in a r...
5 Nov 202414min
S1 Ep1: Depends Who’s Looking
Welcome to the premiere episode of the Astonishing Dead Letter Office, a new weekly show from the creators of Astonishing Legends. For over a decade, you’ve been sending in your strange and unexplaina...
29 Okt 202420min
Your True Halloween Stories III
Once more unto the breach of Halloween, dear friends, once more, as we drift dreamily into some of our listeners’ most eerie encounters! We begin tonight’s fearsome festivities with an account from K...
28 Okt 20243h 12min
