“The ugly sides of two approaches to charity” by Julia_Wise🔸

“The ugly sides of two approaches to charity” by Julia_Wise🔸

Cross-posted from Otherwise. Most EAs won't find these arguments new.

Last month, Emma Goldberg wrote a NYT piece contrasting effective altruism with approaches that refuse to quantify meaningful experiences. The piece indicates that effective altruism is creepily numbers-focused. Goldberg asks “what if charity shouldn’t be optimized?”

The egalitarian answer

Dylan Matthews gives a try at answering a question in the piece: “How can anyone put a numerical value on a holy space” like Notre Dame cathedral? For the $760 million spent restoring the cathedral, he estimates you could prevent 47,500 deaths from malaria.

“47,500 people is about five times the population of the town I grew up in. . . . It's useful to imagine walking down Main Street, stopping at each table at the diner Lou's, shaking hands with as many people as you can, and telling them, ‘I think you need to die to make a cathedral [...]

---

Outline:

(00:29) The egalitarian answer

(01:16) Who prefers magnificence?

(03:10) Inequality has its benefits

(04:34) Is there enough for everybody to have access to the finer things?

(05:37) The balance of good and bad

(06:33) Both sides have ugly aspects

(07:04) These aren't the only choices

(08:58) Related:

The original text contained 1 footnote which was omitted from this narration.

---

First published:
January 13th, 2025

Source:
https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/TiFeCBxKj79bohoDY/the-ugly-sides-of-two-approaches-to-charity

---

Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.

---

Images from the article:

Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.

Det här avsnittet är hämtat från ett öppet RSS-flöde och publiceras inte av Podme. Det kan innehålla reklam.

Avsnitt(250)

“Possible mistake EAs are making and shout out to Pause AI UK” by Michelle_Hutchinson

“Possible mistake EAs are making and shout out to Pause AI UK” by Michelle_Hutchinson

I think right now EAs might be making a significant mistake by paying insufficient attention to the political realm. As EAs we tend to figure out what's most impactful for us to work on and focus hard...

29 Juni 6min

“Coming Around To Political Donations” by Jeff Kaufman 🔸

“Coming Around To Political Donations” by Jeff Kaufman 🔸

Five years ago I read a post on the EA Forum arguing that "election campaign contributions might be a way in which you can have a substantial impact as a small donor". It struck me as weird but plausi...

12 Juni 4min

“animal welfare has an evidence problem” by matthes

“animal welfare has an evidence problem” by matthes

Why I stopped donating to animal welfare charities but feel more motivated than ever to redirect money and talent to the cause. I have wanted to write this post for a while. It is an uncomfortable thi...

6 Juni 26min

“After making sure we don’t all die, this should be the first priority” by Yaqi Grover

“After making sure we don’t all die, this should be the first priority” by Yaqi Grover

A new article went viral on Twitter today: Nan Ransohoff's "The Third Wave of American Philanthropy" (link). Worth reading first. Nan is right about the shape of what's coming: hundreds of billions in...

31 Maj 6min

“My disagreements with CEA’s approach to stewarding EA” by hbesceli

“My disagreements with CEA’s approach to stewarding EA” by hbesceli

[Cross posted from my substack] In their EA Forum post last year, CEA described their ‘principles-first approach to stewardship of the EA community’. I'm a big fan of principles-first stewardship in ...

29 Maj 27min

“Donating 80% While It Still Counts” by Jeff Kaufman 🔸

“Donating 80% While It Still Counts” by Jeff Kaufman 🔸

Julia and I had been giving half since 2014, but in 2025 we drew on our savings to donate 81%. It looks to us like we're in a critical window for keeping the introduction of very powerful AI systems f...

27 Maj 11min

“Why now might be the best time ever to start an animal charity” by Aidan Alexander, Aaron Boddy🔸, Ambitious Impact

“Why now might be the best time ever to start an animal charity” by Aidan Alexander, Aaron Boddy🔸, Ambitious Impact

TL;DR: AIM is running its first incubation round focused exclusively on animal welfare, in partnership with Aaron Boddy (co-founder of Shrimp Welfare Project). It'll run in early 2027, and we’re on th...

26 Maj 7min

“Announcing the Rethink Priorities Cross-Cause Fund” by Rethink Priorities

“Announcing the Rethink Priorities Cross-Cause Fund” by Rethink Priorities

TL;DR Today, based on our multi-year prioritization research, we launch the Rethink Priorities Cross-Cause Fund (CCF). The fund pools donors’ contributions and allocates them to high-impact giving fun...

22 Maj 33min

Populärt inom Samhälle & Kultur

podme-dokumentar
p3-dokumentar
svenska-fall
gynning-berg
en-mork-historia
aftonbladet-krim
tv4-nyheterna-story
badfluence
creepypodden-med-jack-werner
mardromsgasten
aftonbladet-daily
rss-mer-an-bara-morsa
hor-har
killradet
flashback-forever
skaringer-nessvold
de-fyras-gang
spar
historiska-brott
p3-historia