Pom Poms & Payoffs: The Dark Descent of Wanda Holloway

In this case, we talk about the Carpool Detectives, a group of moms with a special set of skills who decided to take on a cold case and prove that the deaths of two members of the community were not a...

4 Jan 52min

It's time for a year-end wrap up episode! We share some of our stats for the year and talk about our favorite episodes and moments of 2025. Listen in to reminisce with us about the year gone by and he...

31 Dec 202529min

We talk about the recent deaths of Rob and Michele Reiner and the subsequent arrest of their son, Nick, in connection with the deaths. We talk about the difficulty in identifying the root cause of agg...

26 Dec 202554min

In this episode, we break down the vital distinction between helping (doing something for someone that they cannot do for themselves) and enabling (doing something for someone that they can and should...

24 Dec 202514min

Y'all, this case is close to Jeannine's heart. We discuss the latest case to rock the college football world, the stalking and dangerous behavior perpetrated (allegedly?) by Sherrone Moore, the now fo...

19 Dec 202558min

Let’s talk about responsibility, accountability, and the link between the two. What does accountability mean, and what does it actually look like? Support the show Disclaimer: Jeannine and Natalie a...

16 Dec 202515min

In this episode we talk about the case of Brandon Johnson, a serial liar, manipulator, and abuser of women. He spent decades victimizing intimate partners in increasingly awful ways, until two brave e...

12 Dec 20251h 32min

It’s the case that launched a thousand theories. Today, we revisit the tragic death of Kathleen Peterson and the murder conviction of her husband, Michael Peterson, as explored in The Staircase. We an...

5 Dec 202556min