The Night Hannah Hill Disappeared S.21 Ep.20
The One With Moons Over My Hammy At The Three Bedroom Apartment By The Porn Shop! AKA THE NIGHT HANNAH HILL DISAPPEARED! Official Description from NBCU: The investigation into 18-year-old Hannah Hil...
19 Aug 1h 10min
Secrets on the Emerald Coast S.34 Ep.49
The One With Dancing Sprites, a Godly Throuple, and So Many Church Secrets We Needed A Tally! AKA SECRETS ON THE EMERALD COAST! Official Description from NBCU: When a young mother disappears after lea...
12 Aug 1h 20min
The Day Dee Disappeared S.34 Ep.63
The One With a Giant X-Ray and a Fiery, Feisty, and Flashy Farmer! AKA THE DAY DEE DISAPPEARED! Official Description from NBCU: When Dee Warner vanishes, a shocking piece of evidence reveals the tru...
5 Aug 1h 9min
The Mushroom Mystery S.34 Ep.61
The One With All The Fungi/Funji Hunting, Men On Bicycles, and a Fake Shark Attack! AKA THE MUSHROOM MYSTERY! Official Description from NBCU: When a woman finds a body on a rural road outside of Ind...
29 Juli 1h 14min
Slow Burn S.34 Ep.59
The One With Colt's Neck and Too Many New Jersey Italian Men To Keep Track Of! AKA The SLOW BURN! Official Description from NBCU: After a deadly fire at a New Jersey mansion, detectives uncover a link...
22 Juli 1h 5min
The Bluegrass Mystery S.34 Ep.57
The One With Mutton Chops And An Aggressively Flirtatious Acoustic Guitar Serenade At The Dog Park! AKA The Bluegrass Mystery! Official Description from NBCU: The disappearance of a loving Kentucky ...
15 Juli 1h 27min
Josh Mankiewicz Returns!
Josh Mankiewicz is back with Kimberly and Katie, and this time they're sitting down in a fancy studio to talk about ALL of his episodes this season, his podcast Trace of Suspicion, prison love letters...
8 Juli 1h 12min
The Curse of Robert the Doll: Patreon Preview!
Enjoy this very special preview of our bonus episode on The Curse of Robert The Doll! In this episode Kimberly and Katie dive deep into the harrowing story of a doll said to be the most haunted doll i...
1 Juli 54min
