77. On Writing Quality Peer Reviews, with Noah A. Smith
NLP Highlights7 Jan 2019

77. On Writing Quality Peer Reviews, with Noah A. Smith

It's not uncommon for authors to be frustrated with the quality of peer reviews they receive in (NLP) conferences. In this episode, Noah A. Smith shares his advice on how to write good peer reviews. The structure Noah recommends for writing a peer review starts with a dispassionate summary of what a paper has to offer, followed by the strongest reasons the paper may be accepted, followed by the strongest reasons it may be rejected, and concludes with a list of minor, easy-to-fix problems (e.g., typos) which can be easily addressed in the camera ready. Noah stresses on the importance of thinking about how the reviews we write could demoralize (junior) researchers, and how to be precise and detailed when discussing the weaknesses of a paper to help the authors see the path forward. Other questions we discuss in this episode include: How to read a paper for reviewing purposes? How long it takes to review a paper and how many papers to review? What types of mistakes to be on the lookout for while reviewing? How to review pre-published work?

Det här avsnittet är hämtat från ett öppet RSS-flöde och publiceras inte av Podme. Det kan innehålla reklam.

Avsnitt(145)

Are LLMs safe?

Are LLMs safe?

Curious about the safety of LLMs? 🤔 Join us for an insightful new episode featuring Suchin Gururangan, Young Investigator at Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence and Data Science Engineer at A...

29 Feb 202442min

"Imaginative AI" with Mohamed Elhoseiny

"Imaginative AI" with Mohamed Elhoseiny

This podcast episode features Dr. Mohamed Elhoseiny, a true luminary in the realm of computer vision with over a decade of groundbreaking research. As an Assistant Professor at KAUST, Dr. Elhoseiny's ...

8 Jan 202423min

142 - Science Of Science, with Kyle Lo

142 - Science Of Science, with Kyle Lo

Our first guest with this new format is Kyle Lo, the most senior lead scientist in the Semantic Scholar team at Allen Institute for AI (AI2), who kindly agreed to share his perspective on #Science of ...

28 Dec 202348min

141 - Building an open source LM, with Iz Beltagy and Dirk Groeneveld

141 - Building an open source LM, with Iz Beltagy and Dirk Groeneveld

In this special episode of NLP Highlights, we discussed building and open sourcing language models. What is the usual recipe for building large language models? What does it mean to open source them? ...

29 Juni 202329min

140 - Generative AI and Copyright, with Chris Callison-Burch

140 - Generative AI and Copyright, with Chris Callison-Burch

In this special episode, we chatted with Chris Callison-Burch about his testimony in the recent U.S. Congress Hearing on the Interoperability of AI and Copyright Law. We started by asking Chris about ...

6 Juni 202351min

139 - Coherent Long Story Generation, with Kevin Yang

139 - Coherent Long Story Generation, with Kevin Yang

How can we generate coherent long stories from language models? Ensuring that the generated story has long range consistency and that it conforms to a high level plan is typically challenging. In this...

24 Mars 202345min

138 - Compositional Generalization in Neural Networks, with Najoung Kim

138 - Compositional Generalization in Neural Networks, with Najoung Kim

Compositional generalization refers to the capability of models to generalize to out-of-distribution instances by composing information obtained from the training data. In this episode we chatted with...

20 Jan 202348min

137 - Nearest Neighbor Language Modeling and Machine Translation, with Urvashi Khandelwal

137 - Nearest Neighbor Language Modeling and Machine Translation, with Urvashi Khandelwal

We invited Urvashi Khandelwal, a research scientist at Google Brain to talk about nearest neighbor language and machine translation models. These models interpolate parametric (conditional) language m...

13 Jan 202335min

Populärt inom Vetenskap

p3-dystopia
dumma-manniskor
allt-du-velat-veta
kapitalet-en-podd-om-ekonomi
rss-ufobortom-rimligt-tvivel
svd-nyhetsartiklar
rss-spraket
rss-vetenskapsradion
rss-vetenskapsradion-2
halsorevolutionen
paranormalt-med-caroline-giertz
medicinvetarna
det-morka-psyket
4health-med-anna-sparre
rss-odla
dumforklarat
sexet
rss-broccolipodden-en-podcast-som-inte-handlar-om-broccoli
vetenskapsradion
hacka-livet