My Response to Sam Harris on the Apple Encryption Debate

My Response to Sam Harris on the Apple Encryption Debate



[ Subscribe to the Podcast: iTunes | Android | RSS ]

[ UPDATE: Much credit to Sam for engaging in the conversation. I’m not sure how people claim he’s closed on this topic when he is clearly open to exploring it. ]

I don't agree with all of it. But this is a very good response to my remarks about encryption. https://t.co/rMl8zgtuWN@danielmiessler— Sam Harris (@SamHarrisOrg) February 28, 2016





I’ve been planning on doing a podcast episode on the Apple encryption debate for some time, but I was unsure of the format I should use.

This problem was just solved for me when I listened to Sam Harris—who is someone I respect greatly—miss the mark significantly in a recent podcast.

The thing that compelled me to respond was the fact that I don’t often disagree with Sam. His logic is usually impeccable, and we often end up with nearly identical opinions.

So it was somewhat surreal to hear him be wrong about something. Or at least disagree with me (which, of course, may not be the same thing).

Anyway, being in information security myself I felt like a response was important.

This essay takes the form of a retort to his comments, followed by my own points and then a summary.

Sam’s points

[ The points are summarized, by the way, not necessarily exact quotes. ]


* Apple built the lock, but didn’t build the key, and now they’re telling us that building the key would put us all at risk. Self-serving abdication of responsibility.
* Community in tech swayed by Snowden. Even when the government gets a court order, they think they shouldn’t give access
* Gives cases where text messages could have helped solve a murder, but the texts are unread because the iPhone is unbreakable. Imagine being a family member!
* Could someone build an impregnable room inside their own house?
* What if you could take a drug that could make your DNA unanalyzable? So you could never be linked to any crime. The only people who would benefit would be criminals!
* Apple could maintain the backdoor and it’d be fine, just like banks have your banking information. They’re trading on paranoia.


My responses

[ NOTE: This will come in the form of a podcast, which I may still record. I wrote it largely in the voice of a spoken conversation. ]

First, let’s start with where we agree.

You speak of a “Cult of Privacy”, where people are blindly saying that Snowden did nothing wrong whatsoever, that he didn’t set a dangerous precedent, that any violation of privacy in any case is always bad, etc., etc.

I absolutely agree with you that this is not an intelligent way to understand and discuss current events.

But there’s another cult on the other side, and it’s one that you’re coming dangerous close to membership in. And that’s “The Cult of Safety”. This one works like this: If there is any situation in which some amount of data could be used to help learn where a kidnapped girl is, or where a terrorist’s bomb will detonate, then it’s within the rights of a government to legally seize ...

Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgrade

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Avsnitt(532)

Unsupervised Learning: No. 173

Unsupervised Learning: No. 173

Amazon has many thousands of people doing quality control on Alexa, meaning that they're listening to incoming audio captured on Echo devices. This shouldn't be surprising. The question is how they're doing it, and what policies they have around privacy when doing so. I don't personally see a major problem here. But at the same time I'd never put a Facebook device in my home. To me it's more about the company and its incentives than anything else. LinkA number of FBI-affiliated websites were hacked, and information on thousands of federal agents and law enforcement officers are now being sold online. LinkChinese schools are using facial recognition on students, and using ML to determine whether or not they're currently paying attention, distracted, etc. LinkSift is a service that builds a risk profile on you so merchants can determine whether you're a benign actor or someone about to commit fraud. I think people need to accept that continuous risk scoring for people and situations is both inevitable and actually already happening. The moment you try to block bad actors by looking at their behavior, you quickly end up with a score that determines action based on various thresholds. And the moment you do it for bad actors, you're kind of implicitly doing it for good actors as well. There are better and worse ways to approach this, but profile scoring is not something we're going to be able to avoid going forward. Let's accept this reality and start having the conversations about how to make (and keep) this functionality as benign as possible. LinkA Dutch F-16 was damaged by rounds from its own 20MM cannon. So it fired bullets, and then flew into them. Life is awesome. LinkBecome a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

14 Apr 201924min

Unsupervised Learning: No. 171

Unsupervised Learning: No. 171

Mastercard is looking to create a Digital ID service that can bind your digital presence to your mobile device, which will be able to verify you to various services. Palantir has won an $800 million contract to build the next combat intelligence system (to replace DCGS-A) for the Army. Putin appears to be causing brain drain in Russia. Dropbox has an interesting proposal for improving vendor security assessments. TL;DR: They turned their requirements into contractual points. LOVE IT. Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

1 Apr 201919min

Unsupervised Learning: No. 169

Unsupervised Learning: No. 169

Multiple governments have now blacklisted Huawei, which Huawei seems very confused by. The best explanation I've heard so far about why this move makes sense for western countries came from Rob Joyce of NSA. He basically said that just like Kaspersky in Russia, the reason you can't trust Huawei is that it's a Chinese company, and even if they're not already infiltrated by the Chinese government, they can be at any moment without anyone knowing that it happened. And there's nothing Huawei or anyone else could do to stop it. Strong argument. Link2/3 of Android antivirus apps are hot garbage. Gasp. LinkDARPA is building an open-source, secure voting system. That's their goal, anyway. I'm skeptical of being able to build truly secure systems, but I have lots of confidence in DARPA, and I also know the bar for improvement over the current state is quite low. So, yeah, go forth and prosper. LinkThe RAND Think Tank conducts wargames between the U.S. and its potential enemies, such as Russia and China, and one analyst said that we keep losing. The issue seems to be that our key advantages can be neutralized rather easily, and it'd take a lot of money to fix the biggest issues. LinkBecome a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

18 Mars 201918min

Unsupervised Learning: No. 167

Unsupervised Learning: No. 167

This is a description of cyberwar that sounds quite realistic to me, and it's based around the thousand-cuts idea. Ring Doorbells have a vulnerability that allows one to capture clear-text videos and other data from the cameras if you can get on the wireless network that the camera is using. An independent security researcher found the Dow Jones Watchlist database sitting open on the internet. Schneier talks here about how easy it is to influence people in sensitive positions, similar to my post on China building a database on us.…Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

3 Mars 201934min

Unsupervised Learning: No. 165

Unsupervised Learning: No. 165

OpenAI text spoofing, Twitter DMs, Chinese tracking database, Ponemon Cyber Risk Score, Technology News, Human News, Ideas Trends & Analysis, Discovery, Recommendations, and the Weekly Aphorism…Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

21 Feb 201923min

Unsupervised Learning: No. 163

Unsupervised Learning: No. 163

My takeaways from ENIGMA 2019—one of my two favorite conferences in the world. The US has charged Huawei with stealing trade secrets, money laundering, and fraud. This escalates the already tense situation with China on a number of fronts. An engineer does a Twitter thread on AI-created videos on YouTube. He describes how they are created, promoted, and selected for display in recommendations. Fascinating read. This is a video of thieves scanning a BMW key fob through the wall of the owner's house, and driving away in their car. It could be that proximity-based security devices might need a trigger event (from the owner) before becoming active, like for mobile payments.Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

4 Feb 201916min

An Overview of the OWASP IoT Top 10 for 2018

An Overview of the OWASP IoT Top 10 for 2018

We just released the 2018 version of the OWASP Internet of Things Top 10, and in this episode I talk you through the list and give the philosophy, methodology, and next steps for the project.Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

7 Jan 201914min

Unsupervised Learning: No. 159

Unsupervised Learning: No. 159

German politicians hacked, NSA's new RE tool, Weather Channel tracking, sick TSA agents, Facebook dust tracking, Technology News, Human News, Ideas, Discovery, Recommendations, and the weekly Aphorism…Become a Member: https://danielmiessler.com/upgradeSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

7 Jan 201928min

Populärt inom Teknik

uppgang-och-fall
rss-racevecka
elbilsveckan
bilar-med-sladd
market-makers
bosse-bildoktorn-och-hasse-p
rss-laddstationen-med-elbilen-i-sverige
skogsforum-podcast
rss-technokratin
developers-mer-an-bara-kod
natets-morka-sida
hej-bruksbil
mediepodden
rss-veckans-ai
ai-sweden-podcast
rss-uppgang-och-fall
bli-saker-podden
rss-it-sakerhetspodden
rss-snacka-om-ai
rss-badfluence