Episode 28: The Gaza Paradox
Ask Haviv Anything14 Juli 2025

Episode 28: The Gaza Paradox

As hostage talks seem stalled and the war grinds on into its 22nd month, doubts about Netanyahu’s strategy and intentions have become ubiquitous.


Netanyahu has given many reasons to distrust him, including his simple refusal to explain the strategy for removing Hamas and Israel’s vision for a post-Hamas Gaza.


But it isn’t enough to criticize Netanyahu’s strategy or even to argue he doesn’t have one. To offer an effective critique, critics need to suggest a better strategy for removing Hamas and securing a better future for Gaza.


So far, criticism of Netanyahu has either avoided this step or suggested that Hamas cannot, in fact, be disentangled from Gaza, that Gaza’s future is inevitably a Hamas future.


In this episode, we dive into these questions. We ask what it would mean for both Israelis and Palestinians if Hamas is, as the critics claim, unremovable.


This episode was sponsored by Bennett and Robin Greenspan of Houston, Texas, strong supporters of Israel who recognize Israel’s centrality and vitality to the Jewish world. They asked us to say that they are proud to sponsor this episode of “Ask Haviv Anything” because this podcast makes understanding the Middle East a bit easier. They have dedicated this episode to the courageous and incredibly imaginative women and men of the Mossad, who make television look boring and simplistic in comparison to their daring exploits behind enemy lines.


Please join me on Patreon to support this project: ⁠www.patreon.com/AskHavivAnything⁠.


If you would like to sponsor an episode, please email us at haviv@askhavivanything.com⁠.


Musical intro by Adam Ben Amitai.

Avsnitt(115)

Episode 70: The warrior Jews who terrified Rome, with Barry Strauss

Episode 70: The warrior Jews who terrified Rome, with Barry Strauss

Between the outbreak of the Jews’ Great Revolt against Rome in the year 66 CE and the final suppression of the Bar Kochba Revolt in 135, the Jews of the Roman Empire constituted the empire’s single bi...

23 Dec 202552min

Episode 69: Israel's great divide - An insider's look at the judicial reform, with Moshe Koppel

Episode 69: Israel's great divide - An insider's look at the judicial reform, with Moshe Koppel

Until October 7, Israel’s politics were consumed by the fight over the government’s judicial reform proposals. The issue drove hundreds of thousands of Israelis to the streets in protest. It triggered...

19 Dec 20251h 37min

Episode 68: Antizionism is inherently violent, with Adam Louis-Klein

Episode 68: Antizionism is inherently violent, with Adam Louis-Klein

After the massacre at Bondi Beach, anthropologist Adam Louis-Klein returns to the podcast to help us make sense of the new Jew-hatred.Antizionism, Adam argues, may be a form of hatred of Jews, but it'...

17 Dec 20251h 1min

Episode 67: Miracles in the dark. A response to Bondi.

Episode 67: Miracles in the dark. A response to Bondi.

This Hanukkah began in darkness, in the brutal massacre of Jews in Sydney, Australia. Our hearts are broken, but our light is not dimmed.In this episode, we dive into the meaning of Hanukkah in the Je...

15 Dec 202548min

Episode 66: Do BDS campaigns help Palestinians?

Episode 66: Do BDS campaigns help Palestinians?

Welcome to our new short-form episodes interspersed with the regular interviews that dive into an often-asked question about Israel, Jews and the Middle East.Our current question: Do BDS campaigns hel...

5 Dec 202512min

Episode 65: The unseen editors rigging the information war, with Ashley Rindsberg

Episode 65: The unseen editors rigging the information war, with Ashley Rindsberg

The internet has democratized information. Or so we are told. The world's knowledge is now at everyone's fingertips. No government and no power structure can gatekeep what everyone sees and hears.But ...

2 Dec 20251h 9min

Episode 64: The Soviet roots of today's antizionism, with Izabella Tabarovsky

Episode 64: The Soviet roots of today's antizionism, with Izabella Tabarovsky

Izabella Tabarovsky is a scholar of Soviet antizionism and contemporary antisemitism, a contributor to many books and a senior fellow at the Z3 Institute. Her latest book is “Be a Refusenik: A Jewish ...

28 Nov 20251h 19min

Episode 63: New York in the age of Tucker and Mamdani, with Noam Dworman

Episode 63: New York in the age of Tucker and Mamdani, with Noam Dworman

Noam Dworman is the owner of the legendary Comedy Cellar comedy club in New York. He a lifelong New Yorker, a podcaster and an astute observer of his city and his country.What does he make of the inco...

25 Nov 202555min

Populärt inom Historia

kod-katastrof
massmordarpodden
historiska-brott
olosta-mord
p3-historia
motiv
rss-historien-om
historiepodden-se
historianu-med-urban-lindstedt
rss-seriemordarpodden
rss-historiska-brottslingar
rss-massmordarpodden
obskyr-historia
harrisons-dramatiska-historia
bedragare
militarhistoriepodden
mannen-utan-spar
nu-blir-det-historia
krigshistoriepodden
rss-folkets-historia