The Fight for Proctor's Phone Data & The Federal Protective Order Dilemma | Case Brief
The Emily Show13 Aug 2025

The Fight for Proctor's Phone Data & The Federal Protective Order Dilemma | Case Brief

Watch the full coverage of the live stream on The Emily D. Baker YouTube channel: https://youtube.com/live/dpvMV9XQhOs Obtaining a federal download of Former Trooper Michael Proctor's phone data is sought by attorneys for multiple defendants in Norfolk County murder cases because it may contain exculpatory evidence. However, Proctor's lawyer claims nothing exculpatory exists outside the federal materials, partly because Proctor got a new phone in February 2024, potentially wiping earlier data. The problem is that the state police and Norfolk DA cannot directly extract this data; they must get it from the feds, who rejected requests for discovery from other prosecutions but turned it over in the Karen Read case. In the Karen Read case, the federal discovery was turned over, but it came with a federal protective order prohibiting its use in other cases. This creates a "boot loop" or "procedural quagmire" because Assistant District Attorney McLaughlin, who worked on the Read case, is aware of potentially exculpatory and impeachment information regarding lead investigator Former Trooper Proctor contained within these federal materials. Under Rule 14, McLaughlin is obligated to disclose the existence of such information to the defense in other cases (like the Walshe case), but the federal protective order prevents the office from physically turning over or even reviewing this material for exculpatory content. This forces the defense to argue for potentially exculpatory evidence they cannot see or definitively prove. RESOURCES Myles King Discovery Hearing August 5 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V_gRWoUtPKY Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Avsnitt(391)

Quick Bits: New Ruby Franke Details. Will Alex Murdaugh lose his plea deal? Baldwin wants his case dismissed.

Quick Bits: New Ruby Franke Details. Will Alex Murdaugh lose his plea deal? Baldwin wants his case dismissed.

Control Body Odor ANYWHERE with @lumedeodorant and get 15% off with promo code EDBQB at LumeDeodorant.com ! #lumepod #ad There was a massive release of videos, photos, and interviews related to the Ru...

1 Apr 202419min

Alec Baldwin wants his case dismissed again. What happens now?

Alec Baldwin wants his case dismissed again. What happens now?

Go to https://fastgrowingtrees.com/ and use code LAWNERD to get 15% off your entire order! Turn your food waste into dirt with the press of a button with Lomi. Use the code LAWNERD to save $50 at http...

27 Mars 20241h 21min

Quick Bits: Baldwin Dismissal Motion. Hannah Gutierrez wants a New Trial, and was Kouri Richins' Mom involved in the death of her husband?

Quick Bits: Baldwin Dismissal Motion. Hannah Gutierrez wants a New Trial, and was Kouri Richins' Mom involved in the death of her husband?

Control Body Odor ANYWHERE with @lumedeodorant and get $5 off of your Starter Pack (that’s over 40% off) with promo code EDBQB at https://lumedeodorant.com ! #lumepod #ad Alec Baldwin has filed a moti...

25 Mars 202418min

State v. Hannah Gutierrez. Trial Summary, Conviction and what's next.

State v. Hannah Gutierrez. Trial Summary, Conviction and what's next.

On March 6, 2024, Hannah Gutierrez, the armorer on the set of Rust, was convicted of involuntary manslaughter. She is set to be sentenced on April 15, 2024, and faces a maximum of 18 months in prison....

20 Mars 202426min

Exclusive Interview. Sir Mix-a-Lot on the future of the music industry, TikTok and AI.

Exclusive Interview. Sir Mix-a-Lot on the future of the music industry, TikTok and AI.

Head to https://factormeals.com/edb50 and use EDB50 to get 50% off! Visit https://thrivecausemetics.com/LAWNERD for 20% off your first order. Go to https://shopify.com/lawnerd now to grow your busines...

13 Mars 20241h 4min

Quick Bits: Hannah Gutierrez, Convicted of Involuntary Manslaughter! Ariana & Tom Sued By Rachel

Quick Bits: Hannah Gutierrez, Convicted of Involuntary Manslaughter! Ariana & Tom Sued By Rachel

Download the free Law Nerd App at https://lawnerdapp.com and get updates and LIVE alerts on all The Emily Show content. Last week the trial of Hannah Gutierrez, the armorer on the set of Rust, ended. ...

11 Mars 202410min

Ariana Madix, Tom Sandoval Sued By Rachel Leviss. Sandoval Fights For The House.

Ariana Madix, Tom Sandoval Sued By Rachel Leviss. Sandoval Fights For The House.

Get 20% OFF @honeylove by going to https://www.honeylove.com/LAWNERD ! #honeylovepod #ad Go to https://shopify.com/lawnerd now to grow your business – no matter what stage you’re in. If you at all pay...

7 Mars 20241h 15min

Quick Bits: Rust Trial Schedule & Updates. Ruby Franke Sentencing. Petito Lawsuit Settled.

Quick Bits: Rust Trial Schedule & Updates. Ruby Franke Sentencing. Petito Lawsuit Settled.

Download the free Law Nerd App at https://lawnerdapp.com and get updates and LIVE alerts on all The Emily Show content. Missed a day in court? Get daily updates on the ongoing Rust trial over on the Q...

4 Mars 20244min

Populärt inom Politik & nyheter

aftonbladet-krim
svenska-fall
p3-krim
blenda-2
rss-krimstad
flashback-forever
rss-sanning-konsekvens
politiken
aftonbladet-daily
motiv
rss-vad-fan-hande
spar
rss-krimreportrarna
svd-ledarredaktionen
grans
dagens-eko
rss-flodet
rss-frandfors-horna
olyckan-inifran
rss-aftonbladet-krim