4x10: The Extra Key - Let's Not Meet (Feat. Sapphire Sandalo)

Stories in this episode: - Creepy Story from 1990, by Breezy (0:50) - The Basement Bathroom by Emilie (5:17) - The Aggressive Good Samaritan, by Gracie (15:32) - Creepy Camouflaged Mountain Man, b...

20 Feb 202348min

Welcome to a new series where we share a bonus story to help get you through that midweek slump. This is a story from a listener named Mav-o-Tav. The story you've heard this week was narrated and pr...

15 Feb 20239min

Stories in this episode: - Cade, by Dannie_Quinn04 (0:49) - Valentine's Night Encounter at Lone Beach, by AmericanRaider76 (9:24) - Creepy Valentine Caller, by Emma (15:24) - Weird Guy on Valenti...

13 Feb 202350min

Welcome to a new series where we share a bonus story to help get you through that midweek slump. This is a story from a listener named Andy. The story you've heard this week was narrated and produce...

8 Feb 20236min

Stories in this episode: - Followed by Drugged Up Gang Members, by June (0:50) - Tales From Downeast Maine, by IAmTheWalrus216 (8:04) - Creepy Man in a Poncho, by A-Ginger6060 (17:32) - Cryptic Cr...

6 Feb 202348min

Stories in this episode: - Doomsday Prepper at the Dive Bar, by Emmet (0:50) - Creepy White Van on Isolated Highway, by Jose (12:46) - Throwing Rocks at a Window Isn't Always Romantic, by Ann (19:...

30 Jan 202351min

Stories in this episode: - Near Miss Abduction, by Rebecca (0:50) - The Two-for-One Creeper Day, by Anonymous (7:52) - Encounter on the Oregon Coast, by teetspydr (17:57)  - I Just Wanted a Plumbe...

23 Jan 202348min

Stories in this episode: - 3 Gunmen Who Stalked My Grandma's House, by Kitty (0:51) - The Devil in the Walls, by Emily (6:37) - Ben, by Kaitlyn (16:17) - Joe, by anon (29:09) - Creepy Unknown Ol...

16 Jan 202353min