4x10: The Extra Key - Let's Not Meet (Feat. Sapphire Sandalo)

Stories in this episode: Bizarre Break-In and Possible Link One Year Later? | communistnymph (0:41) Man in My Backyard | sanrioscr (5:59) We Unknowingly Stayed at a Cult Leader's House | emotional-...

24 Feb 202559min

Stories in this episode: My Rescue Dog Protected Me and My Son | The Devil's Duplicate (1:07) Home Alone With My Old Dog | MaRs1317 (8:29) My Dog Sensed Something About My Daughter's Friend | thare...

17 Feb 202555min

Stories in this episode: I’m Afraid of Roads at 21 | DrPepperEnjoyer69 (0:01) Creepy Man Chasing Me and My Friends | SharkT33th (7:31) The Man in the Black Jacket in Late 80s Moscow | Anoymous (14:27...

10 Feb 202556min

Stories in this episode: Neighbor Scratching on My Door | Anonymous (0:41) My "Biggest Fan" | wynnternow (8:15) I Never Want to Meet My Best Friend Again | shadowsovermexico (15:23) "Her Name Was ...

3 Feb 202553min

Help save our feline friend Ruben! Go to https://www.gofundme.com/f/donate-to-give-ruben-a-chance to help Ruben and his family with his hospital bills! Stories in this episode: Creepy Hike in the ...

27 Jan 202552min

Stories in this episode: Dragged into a Robbery | Fierce_Stiletto21 (0:40) Night Drive in the Mountains | McKave (8:32) Followed for Hours | MrSatanSuperSaiyan (17:04) Man Hiding in My Porch | cor...

20 Jan 202552min

Stories in this episode:  The Man in the Crawlspace | MUKworld (0:41) Not Going Into That Forest Anymore... | Knobig (5:51)  He Cornered Me in a Closet | isabellawolf (12:14)  Mysterious Encounter Ou...

13 Jan 202554min

Stories in this episode:  Christmas Eve Lyft Ride Nightmare | Ges613 (0:40) New Year's Eve Close Call... | NeverMindTheCarrots (6:16)  Ren Groupies Are Scary | Shenko-wolf (14:34)  Creepy guy at LARP...

6 Jan 202550min