The Missing Men of Silver Plume
Crime Clueless22 Okt 2025

The Missing Men of Silver Plume

In the tiny Colorado mountain town of Silver Plume, population barely 200, two men vanished — a year apart — under eerily similar circumstances.

The first was Tom Young, a quiet shopkeeper who disappeared with his dog, leaving behind a locked store and no note. A year later, Keith Reinhard, a journalist writing a novel about a man who mysteriously disappears, walked into those same mountains… and never came back.

What happened in Silver Plume? Was it coincidence, a calculated copycat, or something darker in those peaks that swallow sound and keep their secrets?

In this episode, we trace the unsettling parallels between the two men’s lives, the haunting coincidences that tied them together, and the legends that still echo through that forgotten mining town.

A place that seems peaceful by daylight — but after dark, it’s like the mountains themselves are listening.

To see more about this case, as well as the sources used to create this episode, visit our Blog Here.

Find Crime Clueless socials, website, and more here

Thank you for listening - we are grateful for you!

Support Crime Clueless - Buy Me A Coffee


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Avsnitt(101)

Undetermined: The Death of Molly Young

Undetermined: The Death of Molly Young

Trigger warning, this episode contains extensive discussion on suicide. When 21-year-old artist Molly Young was found dead from a gunshot wound in her ex-boyfriend’s bedroom in Carbondale, Illinois, t...

10 Dec 20251h 24min

A Light in the Dark: The Murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier

A Light in the Dark: The Murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier

Two days before Christmas in 1996, French television producer Sophie Toscan du Plantier was found brutally murdered outside her remote holiday cottage in West Cork, Ireland. Her death shocked the quie...

3 Dec 20251h 34min

Special Crossover Episode - Her Name Was Sonya Ivanoff

Special Crossover Episode - Her Name Was Sonya Ivanoff

This episode was originally released on our sister podcast Vanished Voices, where we focus on under-reported cases and victims who too often go unheard — including Indigenous women, LGBTQ+ victims, an...

26 Nov 202551min

50 Stabs in Broad Daylight: Who Killed Penny Bell?

50 Stabs in Broad Daylight: Who Killed Penny Bell?

On a sunny morning in June 1991, Penny Bell left her beautiful home in Buckinghamshire and told the builders she was late for an appointment. She never came back. Just a couple of hours later, she was...

19 Nov 20251h 11min

The Most Baffling Case You’ve Never Heard Of: David Glenn Lewis

The Most Baffling Case You’ve Never Heard Of: David Glenn Lewis

A respected attorney in Texas sets his VCR to record the Super Bowl… and vanishes. A day later, a John Doe is found dead over 1,600 miles away on a desolate Washington highway—no ID, no car, and dress...

13 Nov 20251h 3min

Three Blocks From Home - The Night Lauren Spierer Vanished

Three Blocks From Home - The Night Lauren Spierer Vanished

On the early morning of June 3, 2011, 20-year-old Indiana University student Lauren Spierer walked out of a friend’s apartment barefoot — leaving behind her phone, shoes, and purse — and vanished some...

5 Nov 20251h 23min

The Halloween Party Murder of Chelsea Bruck

The Halloween Party Murder of Chelsea Bruck

In October 2014, 22-year-old Chelsea Bruck put on her handmade Poison Ivy costume and headed to a massive Halloween party in rural Michigan. She never made it home. What started as a night of fun amon...

29 Okt 20251h 9min

Populärt inom Komedi

mellan-himmel-och-jord-med-jlc
ursakta
alex-sigges-podcast
den-som-skrattar-forlorar-podcast-2
hogt-i-tak-2
gynning-berg
filip-fredrik-svarar
alla-andra-kan-ga-hem
jocke-jonna-sanningen-maste-fram
rss-vafalls
alla-goda-ting-ar-tre
killradet
mardromsgasten
rss-vastgotapodden
skaringer-nessvold
hor-har
flashback-forever
wahlgren-wistam
bygga-at-idioter
rss-alla-goda-ting-ar-tre