20. The Original Axe Murderer?: The Smuttynose Murders
On a chilly evening in early March of 1873, Louis HF Wagner concocted a plan to rob his former employer. When a pup startles the household awake, the night takes a dark and twisted turn. Sources: htt...
15 Apr 202131min
19. Follow The Light: The Abduction of Barney and Betty Hill
Barney and Betty Hill were driving home from their honeymoon when a larger circular light seemed to be following their car. When they pulled over to get a closer look, they could not believe what they...
8 Apr 202130min
18. Killed Over Spilled Milk?: The Strange Vanishing of Ordie Gibson
Orville "Ordie" Gibson was farmer in a quiet Vermont town, who woke up on the morning of New Year's Eve, 1957, ready to start his day. It was a chilly morning when he left to go milk the cows, but wou...
4 Apr 202131min
17. Cry Like You Mean It: The False Confession of Peter Reilly
On September 28, 1973, Peter Reilly returned home after an evening at the teen center to find his mother brutally murdered. How, in the course of twenty-four hours, did Peter go from an innocent teena...
25 Mars 202140min
16. Cold Cases & A Deck of Cards
We've covered every state except Rhode Island, dear thrill-seekers. Join us as we delve into three cold cases and how they all are connected in a way that gives us hope they will be solved. Sources: ...
18 Mars 202132min
15. Breaking Bad: The Massachusetts Drug Lab Scandal
Between 2003 and 2013, two women, at two separate labs, were tampering with critical drug evidence for very different reasons. Today we dive into the cases of Sonja Farak and Annie Dookhan whose falsi...
11 Mars 202142min
14. BONUS: The Dover Demon, Nissitissit Witch, and Flying Babies
Today's eppie is a bit different than others: we are diving into the creepy, unexplained, and (in some cases) comical! Join us for a bonus adventure with equal parts spook and laughter. ATK Book: ht...
7 Mars 202133min
13. The Car Crashed Into The Barn: The Brianna Maitland Case
A month after Maura Murray went missing, Brianna Maitland disappeared only 90 miles away. Are the two cases connected? Did Brianna willingly leave or was she taken by another person? For such a small ...
4 Mars 202146min
