Episode 129: "Roadtrip to Missouri: Buck Nelson Goes to Space"
We are taking the old New York Mystery Machine on the road to Missouri where we find a guy claiming to be the first man abducted by aliens and taken to many planets in space during the 1950's. Did thi...
1 Apr 20241h 3min
Episode 128: "The Murder of Lulu Bailey"
No one knew Lulu Bailey was going to see Doctor Edwin Carman in Freeport the night of June 30, 1914 -- so who would shoot her through the doctor's office window? Learn more about this case on this wee...
25 Mars 202449min
Episode 127: "Ludwig the Bloodsucker!"
Did we find New York's first vampire?! While, the urban legend of Ludwig the Bloodsucker was making the rounds in the Bowery section of the Lower East Side, a German man who seemingly matches the desc...
18 Mars 202451min
Episode 126: "The 3x Killer"
This week's perpetrator has an unusual MO: he kills men in lovers lanes, escorts the women to the bus, and then sends rambling notes to the police. Find out about this unusual whodunnit and be sure to...
11 Mars 202447min
Episode 125: "Cropsey: Urban Legend and Real Life Monster"
Throughout the 70s and 80s children all over Staten Island told stories of a hook handed monster who would snatch them up and bring them into the woods. But, around the same time parent became concern...
4 Mars 202452min
Episode 124: "Who Killed Hot Maggie?"
Maggie Hourigan was a beautiful, mild-mannered, upstanding young woman when she was killed by attacker or attackers unknown. Who killed Maggie Hourigan? Explore the evidence on this week's episode, an...
26 Feb 202448min
Episode 123: "Missing in Poughkeepsie"
In 2001, a 31-year-old man received a mysterious page on his beeper. He told his parents he was meeting a friend to play pool...and he was never heard from again? What happened to him? Did he run away...
19 Feb 202455min
Episode 122: "Dalí Goes to...and Escapes from Rikers"
Did you know there was a Dalí at Rikers Island jail? "Was" is the operative word here - in March 2003, the painting disappeared. Learn the history of and last known whereabouts of this painting on thi...
5 Feb 202443min
