Episode 51: "The Amityville Horror"
Last week we focused on Chapter One of the Amityville Saga, the DeFeo Murders. This week, a new family has moved into the home and the paranormal has moved in with them! This episode has everything......
25 Juli 202253min
Episode 50: "The Amityville Murders"
Welcome to Season 2 of The New York Mystery Machine! This week we focus on the first part of the legendary Amityville Horror. On November 13, 1974, at around 6:30 p.m., 23-year-old Ronald "Butch" DeFe...
24 Juli 202246min
Episode 49: "Season 1 Finale: New Theories & Info from our Past!"
Well, can you believe we started this journey a year ago?! Today, for our Season 1 Finale, we are exploring some of our past episodes from this season and discovering new theories while trying to solv...
27 Juni 202258min
Episode 48: "The Mysterious Death of Marsha P. Johnson"
Happy Pride Month! This episode we are honoring a legend of the LGBTQ+ Community who died under mysterious circumstances. Marsha "Pay it No Mind" Johnson, a prominent Trans Activist who fought at Ston...
20 Juni 202249min
Episode 47: "The (Jersey) Devil is in the Details"
Even devout New Yorkers need to quit the city once in a while! This week Adam and Christina are going on a little roadtrip to New Jersey to investigate the state's only official demon: The Jersey Devi...
13 Juni 202257min
Episode 46: "The Crime of the Century - The Murder of Stanford White"
If you've never heard the name Stanford White and you've spent any time in NYC, you certainly know his work. Him and his firm McKim, Mead, and white designed many things in NYC from the Washington Par...
6 Juni 202253min
Episode 45: "The Assassination of President McKinley"
New York is home to one of four Presidential Assassinations. On September 5, 1901, Leon Czolgosz would shoot President William McKinley at point blank range while the President was greeting visitors a...
30 Maj 202247min
Episode 44: "Secrets Built Around Secrets: The Hidden Life of Hazel Drew"
The more investigators prodded into Hazel's life, the more they found that just didn't add up. Who was she waiting for at the train station? What was she doing on Taborton Road at dusk? And who are th...
23 Maj 202248min
