Michael Dunahee Part 2: 11,000 Tips, A Case Hampered by Its Era, and Why This Case Could Still Be Solved

Part 1 covered the afternoon of March 24th, 1991 — the playground, the fifty people who saw nothing, the boy who was there and then wasn't. Part 2 picks up where that left off, with 35 years of investigation, the leads that closed without answers, and where the case stands in 2026.

The investigation that followed Michael Dunahee's disappearance was one of the largest missing child responses in Canadian history. Nearly 100 officers from agencies across British Columbia were mobilized within days. The FBI provided support. America's Most Wanted covered the case multiple times. And the tip system they built on the fly — tips written on carbon paper, sorted by hand — crashed under the weight of calls before a dedicated line could be established.

Victoria Police have since acknowledged that if modern technology had existed in 1991 — video surveillance, computerized tip management, advanced DNA analysis — the case might have been solved in those first few days. It was not a failure of effort. It was a description of the environment.

In 2009, police in Milwaukee searched the home of a man named Vernon Seitz — a 62-year-old who had confessed to his psychiatrist that he killed a child in 1959 and had knowledge of another killing. When they searched the home, they found child pornography, files on missing children cases from the late 1980s and 1990s, and a missing person poster of Michael Dunahee. Alongside the poster: a map labeled "Mill Stream Park," north of Victoria. Victoria Police were contacted. Before the connection could be fully resolved, Seitz was found dead, apparently of natural causes. No definitive link to Michael was ever established.

DNA tests in 2006, 2011, and 2013 each ruled out men who bore physical similarities to Michael. A tip through a Vancouver Canucks fan forum in 2013 led investigators to Surrey. On September 9, 2013, VicPD confirmed that man was not Michael either.

11,000 tips. Multiple serious DNA leads. Not one confirmed connection.

Kevin covers the Amber Alert question directly — what the system requires, why it would not have applied to Michael's case, and what that means. He draws the parallel to Morgan Nick, who disappeared from a little league parking lot in Arkansas in 1995 under strikingly similar circumstances — a public place, a parent nearby, no witnesses, no resolution. And he explains what Child Find BC is, what Crystal Dunahee built from it, and what the annual Keep the Hope Alive Fund Run in Esquimalt means to the Victoria community.

The case is still open. A detective is still assigned. And the tools available to investigators in 2026 are categorically different from 1991: forensic genetic genealogy, advanced facial recognition, and the ability to digitally cross-reference 11,000 tips in ways that were impossible when they were written on carbon paper.

Michael Dunahee would be 40 years old today. His family has never given up hope.

If you have information about Michael Dunahee's disappearance:
Victoria Police Department tip line: 250-995-7444
Online tips: vicpd.ca

ECHO 1953 - THE HOLLIS FILES, BOOK ONE
Launching July 27, 2026. Pre-order on Amazon now.

THE HALLS OF MEDIOCRITY
Sports. True crime. Athletes who had everything and threw it away.
Launching July 14, 2026. Find us wherever you get your podcasts.

MIDNIGHT MYSTERY ARCHIVE
True crime. Cold cases. Every Friday.
midnightmysteryarchive.com | Patreon

Follow us: X | Facebook Group

Thanks to our monthly supporters

• William
• jared K
• Lisa Mooney
• Jamie Mcconnell

★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★