#336 Whether Antidepressants Actually Work and the Myth of Serotonin Imbalance | Professor Joanna Moncrieff

Today we’re having an uncomfortable but very necessary conversation about antidepressants and the theory that these drugs work for those with depression by correcting imbalanced chemicals in their brain.

Our guest to discuss this topic is Joanna Moncrieff, a Professor of Psychiatry at University College London, and works as a consultant psychiatrist in the NHS. She is author of numerous scientific papers including a major review that showed there was little evidence to support the idea that depression is caused by a serotonin abnormality. Her most recent book "Chemically Imbalanced: the making and unmaking of the serotonin myth” is what we’re going to be discussing today.

This was a complete eye opener for me. For years I believed in the pharmaceutical washed message that antidepressants worked because of a genuine brain chemical imbalance that we corrected with medications. This is not proven.

Today we’ll discuss over-use and misrepresentation of psychiatric drugs in the public sphere, the changing philosophy of mental health and how we got to a point where over 8 million people in the UK use antidepressants.

We discuss what serotonin is, how we measure it in the body, why the imbalance theory is inconclusive, whether antidepressants have good evidence that they work and their many side effects.

I want to make it clear that this episode is not meant to shame or belittle anyone on medications for mental health, but provide accurate information about how we can safely treat these problems and offer informed consent weighing up the pros and cons of medications like antidepressants. The use of these medications has well recognised withdrawal and dependency effects and should not be stopped without strict supervision of your medical practitioner.

We’ve also linked to the Maudsley deprescribing guidelines here in the show notes for practitioners educating themselves on how to do this with their patients.

Chemically Imbalanced Book

Website: https://joannamoncrieff.com/

🎬 Watch the podcast on YouTube here

📱 Download The Doctor’s Kitchen app

🌐 View full show notes, including guest details, on our website

☕️ Try Exhale Coffee here

🥗 Join the newsletter and receive a 7 day meal plan

📷 Follow on Instagram

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Denne episoden er hentet fra en åpen RSS-feed og er ikke publisert av Podme. Den kan derfor inneholde annonser.

Episoder(430)

A nutritionist’s guide to 30g of protein and over 10g of fibre in every meal | Dominique Ludwig

I’ve been talking a lot about eating healthy high protein. And sometimes it feels like you have to choose a side. High protein or plant-focused.But both play really important roles for energy, appetit...

12 Aug 1h 4min

4 ways your thoughts affect your metabolism, gut and longevity | Sarah Ann Macklin

What if I told you that two people could eat the exact same meal, with the exact same calories, and have completely different hormonal responses because of what they believed about what they were eati...

29 Jul 1h 5min

5 signs of low fibre and how to eat 30g a day without getting bloated | Dr Emily Leeming

I’ve been talking a lot about healthy protein and sometimes it can feel like you have to pick a side. Protein or fibre. But for long-term health, you want both on your plate.The problem is, 96% of peo...

15 Jul 1h 22min

5 foods to lose fat, regulate your appetite and improve your metabolism without counting calories | Dr Federica Amati

What’s the healthiest way to lose weight and keep it off without counting calories?On paper, it sounds simple. But in a modern world of ultra-processed foods, clever marketing and disrupted hunger sig...

1 Jul 1h 27min

4 ways to ease bloating, constipation and improve your gut health beyond diet | Dr Rabia Topan

SHOW NOTESThis episode is for anyone dealing with constipation, bloating, reflux, abdominal pain or IBS.And really, anyone who wants to protect their gut, reduce stress and feel better overall.When we...

17 Jun 1h 21min

Think clearer and feel calmer with these 7 food strategies from neuroscientist Dr Miguel Toribio-Mateas

What we eat, and how we eat, can have a profound effect on our brain health, even influencing depression, anxiety and ADHD.Today, we’re unpacking simple food strategies that can support your nervous s...

3 Jun 1h 22min

7 Health benefits of fibremaxxing and how to build a high fibre diet | Dr Karan Rajan

I’m seeing fibre maxxing everywhere right now. And I think it might be one of the few trends actually worth paying attention to.But as always, it’s not that simple.This episode is a deep dive into fib...

20 Mai 1h 5min

What to do when you feel overwhelmed and can't switch off | Dr Julie Smith

In this episode, we're building an emotional toolkit for something a lot of us are dealing with: overwhelm.That feeling of too much coming at you at once. The pressure to get everything right with you...

6 Mai 1h 18min