The Cemetery Thief: Selling the Dead for Profit

In this episode of The Jim Rathmann Show, Jim dives into one of the most depraved criminal cases of his career—one that blurs the line between a criminal investigation and a real-life horror movie. When historic graves began to be desecrated at the Civil War–era Mount Moriah Cemetery near Philadelphia, investigators expected a case of simple vandalism; instead, they uncovered a gruesome, multi-state enterprise run by 34-year-old Jonathan Gerlach. Jim breaks down the investigation that led to the discovery of over 100 sets of human remains hidden in Gerlach’s home and storage units, ranging from centuries-old skeletons to recent burials still containing pacemakers and even the remains of infants.

Jim walks you through every chilling detail of the investigation, beginning with how old-school police instincts combined with modern license plate readers and DNA evidence to catch a grave robber in the act. He takes you inside the search warrants that uncovered a macabre collection of bodies staged for display and skulls packaged for shipment, revealing the dark pipeline to the online oddities market. You’ll learn how stolen remains are funneled through private Facebook groups and digital marketplaces to oddities collectors seeking everything from human bones for "art" to skin for tanning. Jim also exposes the shocking legal loopholes regarding "antique" remains that allow this underground oddities trafficking to persist across state lines, while reflecting on the devastating emotional toll inflicted on families whose loved ones were stolen from their final resting places.

Follow Jim on Instagram: @therealjimrathmann

Special thanks to our partners: Podgo and Hi Hello Labs in Orlando, Florida, for powering and producing this show.

Sponsored by: Podgo Services

Produced at: Hi Hello Labs (Orlando, FL)

Disclaimer: This episode contains descriptions of grave desecration and the handling of human remains. Listener discretion is strongly advised. The information shared is for educational and awareness purposes only.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.