Keith Reed | The Trail of Evidence
In 2012, a New York school superintendent didn’t show up as expected at a conference. His brother, a former FBI agent, suspected the worst and he was right. The police had leads but it took just one t...
3 Jun 51min
Leda Files | A Daughter's Story
Content disclaimer: This episode contains strong language.In 2025, a man called 911 to report finding his mother dead. But with a changing story and questions about his mental state, the victim’s daug...
20 Mai 1h 7min
Brandi Celenza | The Evolution of a Story
When Brandi Celenza was shot in April of 2018, the police were told one story. That story was the same in 2018, 2019, and 2020. It only changed shortly before the case went to trial and the question c...
6 Mai 55min
Bill and Opal Arnold | The Lives of William Leslie "Les" Arnold
From the time he murdered his parents as a teenager until his death under an assumed name, William Les Arnold’s life intersected with several other people and it left many of them wondering who was he...
16 Apr 1h
Part 2: John and Joan Robinson Hill
In 1969, Joan Robinson Hill died of an infection of unknown origin. Her father was sure it was murder and, due to pressure, charges were eventually filed. But what happened next muddied the water more...
5 Apr 1h 2min
Part One: John and Joan Robinson Hill | Decades of Questions
When Joan Robinson Hill died in 1969, her father was sure foul play was involved even after multiple autopsies ruled it was natural causes. The state ended up charging her husband under a rarely used ...
1 Apr 1h 14min
Kara Nichols | Victimization
When Kara Nichols went missing, her family released relevant details of her life even though they thought it may impede getting attention on the case. It turned out they were right, until the right in...
18 Mar 48min
