#123 – Samuel Charap on why Putin invaded Ukraine, the risk of escalation, and how to prevent disaster

#123 – Samuel Charap on why Putin invaded Ukraine, the risk of escalation, and how to prevent disaster

Russia's invasion of Ukraine is devastating the lives of Ukrainians, and so long as it continues there's a risk that the conflict could escalate to include other countries or the use of nuclear weapons. It's essential that NATO, the US, and the EU play their cards right to ideally end the violence, maintain Ukrainian sovereignty, and discourage any similar invasions in the future.

But how? To pull together the most valuable information on how to react to this crisis, we spoke with Samuel Charap — a senior political scientist at the RAND Corporation, one of the US's foremost experts on Russia's relationship with former Soviet states, and co-author of Everyone Loses: The Ukraine Crisis and the Ruinous Contest for Post-Soviet Eurasia.

Links to learn more, summary and full transcript.

Samuel believes that Putin views the alignment of Ukraine with NATO as an existential threat to Russia — a perhaps unreasonable view, but a sincere one nevertheless. Ukraine has been drifting further into Western Europe's orbit and improving its defensive military capabilities, so Putin has concluded that if Russia wants to put a stop to that, there will never be a better time to act in the future.

Despite early successes holding off the Russian military, Samuel is sceptical that time is on the Ukrainian side. If the war is to end before much of Ukraine is reduced to rubble, it will likely have to be through negotiation, rather than Russian defeat.

The US policy response has so far been largely good, successfully balancing the need to punish Russia to dissuade large nations from bullying small ones in the future, while preventing NATO from being drawn into the war directly — which would pose a horrifying risk of escalation to a full nuclear exchange. The pressure from the general public to 'do something' might eventually cause national leaders to confront Russia more directly, but so far they are sensibly showing no interest in doing so.

However, use of nuclear weapons remains a low but worrying possibility.

Samuel is also worried that Russia may deploy chemical and biological weapons and blame it on the Ukrainians.

Before war broke out, it's possible Russia could have been satisfied if Ukraine followed through on the Minsk agreements and committed not to join the EU and NATO. Or it might not have, if Putin was committed to war, come what may. In any case, most Ukrainians found those terms intolerable.

At this point, the situation is even worse, and it's hard to see how an enduring ceasefire could be agreed upon. On top of the above, Russia is also demanding recognition that Crimea is part of Russia, and acceptance of the independence of the so-called Donetsk and Luhansk People's Republics. These conditions — especially the second — are entirely unacceptable to the Ukrainians. Hence the war continues, and could grind on for months or even years until one side is sufficiently beaten down to compromise on their core demands.

Rob and Samuel discuss all of the above and also:

• The chances that this conflict leads to a nuclear exchange
• The chances of regime change in Russia
• Whether the West should deliver MiG fighter jets to Ukraine
• What are the implications if Sweden and/or Finland decide to join NATO?
• What should NATO do now, and did it make any mistakes in the past?
• What's the most likely situation for us to be looking at in three months' time?
• Can Ukraine effectively win the war?

Chapters:

  • Rob’s intro (00:00:00)
  • The interview begins (00:01:40)
  • Putin's true motive (00:02:29)
  • What the West could have done differently (00:07:44)
  • Chances of Ukraine holding out (00:11:40)
  • Chances of regime change in Russia (00:14:59)
  • The good and the bad from the West so far (00:17:55)
  • Should the West deliver MiG fighter jets to Ukraine? (00:19:57)
  • "No-fly zones" (00:21:32)
  • Chances that this conflict leads to a nuclear exchange (00:26:06)
  • What listeners should do (00:36:01)
  • Chances of biological or chemical weapons use (00:37:59)
  • Best realistic outcome from here (00:39:29)
  • Keeping the broader conversation sane (00:49:29)
  • Why not promise to remove sanctions? (00:51:05)
  • Pros and cons of Sweden and FInland joining NATO (00:52:53)
  • The most likely situation in 3 months (00:53:58)

Producer: Keiran Harris
Audio mastering: Ben Cordell
Transcriptions: Katy Moore

Episoder(321)

#173 – Jeff Sebo on digital minds, and how to avoid sleepwalking into a major moral catastrophe

#173 – Jeff Sebo on digital minds, and how to avoid sleepwalking into a major moral catastrophe

"We do have a tendency to anthropomorphise nonhumans — which means attributing human characteristics to them, even when they lack those characteristics. But we also have a tendency towards anthropoden...

22 Nov 20232h 38min

#172 – Bryan Caplan on why you should stop reading the news

#172 – Bryan Caplan on why you should stop reading the news

Is following important political and international news a civic duty — or is it our civic duty to avoid it?It's common to think that 'staying informed' and checking the headlines every day is just wha...

17 Nov 20232h 23min

#171 – Alison Young on how top labs have jeopardised public health with repeated biosafety failures

#171 – Alison Young on how top labs have jeopardised public health with repeated biosafety failures

"Rare events can still cause catastrophic accidents. The concern that has been raised by experts going back over time, is that really, the more of these experiments, the more labs, the more opportunit...

9 Nov 20231h 46min

#170 – Santosh Harish on how air pollution is responsible for ~12% of global deaths — and how to get that number down

#170 – Santosh Harish on how air pollution is responsible for ~12% of global deaths — and how to get that number down

"One [outrageous example of air pollution] is municipal waste burning that happens in many cities in the Global South. Basically, this is waste that gets collected from people's homes, and instead of ...

1 Nov 20232h 57min

#169 – Paul Niehaus on whether cash transfers cause economic growth, and keeping theft to acceptable levels

#169 – Paul Niehaus on whether cash transfers cause economic growth, and keeping theft to acceptable levels

"One of our earliest supporters and a dear friend of mine, Mark Lampert, once said to me, “The way I think about it is, imagine that this money were already in the hands of people living in poverty. I...

26 Okt 20231h 47min

#168 – Ian Morris on whether deep history says we're heading for an intelligence explosion

#168 – Ian Morris on whether deep history says we're heading for an intelligence explosion

"If we carry on looking at these industrialised economies, not thinking about what it is they're actually doing and what the potential of this is, you can make an argument that, yes, rates of growth a...

23 Okt 20232h 43min

#167 – Seren Kell on the research gaps holding back alternative proteins from mass adoption

#167 – Seren Kell on the research gaps holding back alternative proteins from mass adoption

"There have been literally thousands of years of breeding and living with animals to optimise these kinds of problems. But because we're just so early on with alternative proteins and there's so much ...

18 Okt 20231h 54min

#166 – Tantum Collins on what he’s learned as an AI policy insider at the White House, DeepMind and elsewhere

#166 – Tantum Collins on what he’s learned as an AI policy insider at the White House, DeepMind and elsewhere

"If you and I and 100 other people were on the first ship that was going to go settle Mars, and were going to build a human civilisation, and we have to decide what that government looks like, and we ...

12 Okt 20233h 8min

Populært innen Fakta

fastlegen
dine-penger-pengeradet
relasjonspodden-med-dora-thorhallsdottir-kjersti-idem
treningspodden
rss-strid-de-norske-borgerkrigene
foreldreradet
jakt-og-fiskepodden
rss-sunn-okonomi
merry-quizmas
hverdagspsyken
rss-mann-i-krise-med-sagen
gravid-uke-for-uke
sinnsyn
generasjonspodden
fryktlos
rss-kunsten-a-leve
rss-impressions-2
hagespiren-podcast
teknologi-og-mennesker
rss-ifengsel-podden