127: Where Is Robert Fisher?
In 2001, Robert Fisher murdered his wife and two young kids. And then vanished into thin air. Is he dead, or did he escape to a new life…THIS IS THE QUESTION POSED TO THE PSYCHIC WHO CLOSES OUT THIS…....
7 Apr 202058min
126: The Man Who Would Be Polka King
UMMMMMM, So we have a lot of questions. We can’t wait for you to meet Jan Lewan, the “Polka God” at the center of this thing. But we also can’t wait for you to meet his wife Rhonda, who definitely did...
31 Mar 202057min
125: Dahmer on Dahmer: Part 2
Two-and-a-half decades ago, a man from Milwaukee named Jeffrey Dahmer was tried and convicted of 17 gruesome murders that occurred between 1978 and 1991. Dahmer was convicted of luring young men into ...
24 Mar 202053min
124: Dahmer on Dahmer: Part 1
This is part 1 of a 2 part series. Part 2 is available RIGHT NOW AND AD FREE for one week at the $5 level on Patreon. It will be our regular episode (with ads) next week. Two-and-a-half decades ago,...
17 Mar 202055min
Killer Inside: The Mind of Aaron Hernandez Part 1 (Patreon Bonus Episode)
Patrick may be from Massachusetts (and has the Dunkin Donuts loyalty card to prove it), but he somehow missed out on Boston sports fever (feee-vah!). We have a lot of feelings about this one, but we'...
10 Mar 202048min
123: Oxygen's "Up and Vanished"
On October 21, 2005, local beauty queen, Tara Grinsted vanished from her home in Ocilla, Georgia. 12 years later, two men were arrested for her murder. This was thanks in part to Payne Lindsay's popul...
3 Mar 202049min
Obsessed With: Abducted in Plain Sight Ep 1: One Year Later (Our first-ever spinoff podcast!)
HERE'S EPISODE 1 OF OUR FIRST-EVER SPINOFF PODCAST! For Patrick, this new podcast has been year long labor of love! Please take a listen! It's been a year since the smash hit documentary Abducted in ...
2 Mar 202023min
122: A Tale of Two Thieves
August 1963. Sears Crossing, Buckinghamshire, England. Fifteen men pull off "The Great Train Robbery," netting today's equivalent of almost $70 million. It’s one of the most famous crimes in the histo...
25 Feb 202048min
