Revisiting the Pickton Case with Dr. Sasha Reid & Sue Brown. Part 2.

Voices from the Shadows PART 2

This powerful dialogue between Dr. Sasha Reid (psychologist, advocate, and creator of the Missing Murder Database)

Sue Brown (lawyer with Justice for Girls) delves into systemic failures in addressing violence against marginalized women and girls, particularly Indigenous communities in British Columbia.

Centered on the Robert Pickton case, the conversation critiques institutional apathy, police negligence, and the destruction of critical evidence. Key themes include the intersection of organized crime, human trafficking, and colonial legacies; the RCMP’s systemic incompetence; and the urgent need for transparency, accountability, and structural reform to protect vulnerable populations.

Key Takeaways for Listeners:

• Systemic Neglect of Indigenous Women & Girls:

  • BC accounts for 20% of Canada’s missing/murdered Indigenous women and girls, exacerbated by poverty, lack of infrastructure, and colonial policies.

  • Failures in foster care, education, and economic opportunities heighten vulnerability to exploitation.

• Organized Crime & Trafficking:

  • Drug and human trafficking networks are deeply intertwined in BC, targeting marginalized communities.

  • Predators exploit geographic isolation (e.g., Highway of Tears) and poverty to victimize Indigenous girls.

• RCMP Incompetence & Secrecy:

  • Police dismiss reports of violence, especially against Indigenous women, with responses ranging from indifference to outright hostility.

  • Officers lack training on modern issues like social media exploitation and trafficking.

  • Systemic secrecy obstructs access to case files, undermining public accountability.

• Destruction of Pickton Case Evidence:

  • Over 185,000 exhibits tied to Pickton’s crimes have been destroyed since 2021, erasing potential leads for unsolved cases.

  • Families of victims were not consulted, violating their right to justice and closure.

• Dr. Reid’s Missing Murder Database (MMD):

  • A grassroots, nationally representative database tracks over 11,800 unsolved cases, exposing clusters of violence ignored by authorities.

  • Highlights Canada’s lack of a national missing/murdered persons database.

• Calls for Systemic Change:

  • Dismantle colonial institutions: Reform or replace the RCMP, rooted in racism and misogyny.

  • Fund critical infrastructure: Address poverty, housing insecurity, and rural isolation.

  • Independent oversight: Create non-police bodies to investigate police misconduct and ensure transparency.

  • Preserve evidence: Halt destruction of cold case materials and prioritize victim families’ rights.

• Vancouver’s “Perfect Storm” for Violence:

  • Geographic factors (remote areas, dense forests) and economic disparities (Downtown Eastside poverty, resource extraction “boom towns”) create ideal conditions for predators.

  • Historical patterns of serial killers targeting vulnerable populations remain unaddressed.

• Grassroots Advocacy & Hope:

  • Organizations like Justice for Girls and the Midnight Order fight for accountability, support families, and push for international human rights scrutiny.

  • Sue Brown emphasizes: “Transparency is a pillar of democracy—we can’t assess justice if we’re kept in the dark.”