Episode 524: The Unsolved Murders of Sherry Lewis and Charlotte Fimiano
In August 1994, Sherry Lewis was showing a vacant home in Decatur, Illinois before attending the town’s summer celebration festival. When she didn’t show up, her family was concerned. Then, Sherry was...
14 Jul 34min
Episode 523: The Life & Murder of Reagan Simmons Hancock by Taylor Parker
Taylor Parker murdered 21‑year‑old Reagan Simmons‑Hancock on October 9, 2020, in Reagan’s New Boston, Texas home while Reagan was 36 weeks pregnant. Parker had spent nearly a YEAR faking her own preg...
10 Jul 1h 14min
Episode 522: Suzanne Pilley
When Suzanne Pilley didn’t show up for work at her office in Edinburgh, Scotland on May 4, 2010, everyone who knew her was immediately concerned. When nearly 2 month passed and there was still no sign...
7 Jul 39min
Episode 521: Listener Stories Volume 53
For this months listeners stories we asked for your best roommate horror/nightmare stories and boy did y’all deliver! Plus we share our own stories too! To submit your own listener stories or case su...
3 Jul 53min
Episode 520: The Murder of Dominic Russo and Davion Flanagan
In the early morning hours of July 31st, 2022, 17-year-old Mackenzie Shirilla drove her car over 100mph into a brick building in Strongsville, Ohio. Mackenzie survived the crash, but the other two pas...
30 Jun 1h 5min
Episode 519: The Brown's Chicken Massacre
The Brown’s Chicken massacre is remembered not just as a crime, but as a heartbreaking moment when seven ordinary people living ordinary lives never came home. On January8, 1993, two men walked into a...
26 Jun 1h
Episode 518: The Beast of Blenheim
In the 1970s and 80s, a string of horrific attacks on women and children were happening in Blenheim, New Zealand and surrounding areas. In 1996, a man was identified in several attacks that had taken ...
23 Jun 36min
Episode 517: The Tragic Case of Kayla Huff
Kayla Rose Huff, a 16‑year‑old from Moberly, Missouri, was reported missing on May 6, 2026, after she failed to return home and stopped responding to her family. She was last seen walking with her 17‑...
19 Jun 48min
