16. The Murder of William Blodgett
After 14 years of questions and agonizing pain, a New Mexico family got heartbreaking confirmation of their worst fear... William "Bill" Blodgett was dead. The 69-year-old had gone missing in the days...
26 Jun 202330min
15. The Murder of Skylea Carmack with Kayla Sullivan
This week we welcome our third guest to the podcast. Our friend and former colleague, Kayla Sullivan, joins us to discuss the shocking murder of 10-year-old Skylea Carmack in Grant County, Indiana. Ka...
19 Jun 202348min
14. The Monical's Murder
In March of 1989, two employees at the Monical's Pizza in Danville, Illinois were closing up shop when a man came in for a last-minute order. The two staffers were then shot in the head and left for d...
12 Jun 202331min
13. Natalia Barnett: The Real Life Orphan?
Is she a six-year-old orphan or a 'con artist' adult? This week we're diving head first into one of the strangest cases we've ever covered. In 2019, an Indiana couple was charged with neglect after le...
5 Jun 202348min
12. The Murder of Charles "Chip" Flynn
In 1989, Charles "Chip" Flynn was found shot in a Florida citrus grove. He had been hanging out with his ex-girlfriend, who claims the duo had been robbed and carjacked by a black man. Despite inconsi...
29 Mai 202342min
11. The Mysterious Death of Garnet Ginn
This week we’re diving into one of Indiana’s oldest cold cases. In 1950, high school teacher Garnet Ginn was found dead in her garage. Her body was discovered hanging from the handle of her car door. ...
22 Mai 202344min
10. The Disappearance of Amiah Robertson with Angela Brauer
We're back with a very special guest! This week our friend and former colleague, Angela Brauer joins us to talk about the 2019 disappearance of 8-month-old Amiah Robertson in Indianapolis. This was a ...
15 Mai 202339min
9. The Murder of Amanda Davies
Fresh off her first college spring break in 1992, Amanda Davies was excited to develop photos from her trip. As soon as she returned to her Michigan home, she headed right back out the door to show of...
8 Mai 202350min
