96 | The Evidence Locker | Ellen Rae Greenberg
You asked for it, and the three mustaches listened. This week, we're cracking open the Evidence Locker and bringing you an previously unreleased episode! On a cold, winter night in 2011, 28-year-old E...
20 Nov 20251h 45min
95 | Emily Noble | Suicide Surrounds Them
The three mustaches take a journey to the greatest state in America to cover the tragic case of Emily Noble. In May of 2020, in Westerville, Ohio, police received a report of a woman that was possibly...
13 Nov 20252h 19min
94 | Kristil Krug | Stalk a Mile in My Shoes
The three mustaches travel to Colorado to cover the case of Kristil Krug and her noodly-armed husband, Daniel. When Kristil rejects the advances of a former boyfriend, she soon learns that her old fla...
6 Nov 20252h 13min
93 | Lois Riess | The Gambling Granny
The three mustaches grab their lucky four-leaf clovers to cover the case of Losing Streak Lois. This poor woman just couldn’t seem to catch a break. First her husband gets gunned down in their own hom...
30 Okt 20252h 20min
92 | Donna Adelson | All in the Family
The three mustaches get together to tackle a convoluted, murder-for-hire case out of Tallahassee, Florida. When 41-year-old law professor, Dan Markel, is brutally gunned down in his driveway by two me...
23 Okt 20252h 33min
91 | Donna Scrivo | Donna Dearest
The three mustaches put on some leathers and hop into their war rig to tackle a case from the post-apocalyptic wasteland known as Detroit. When Donna Scrivo’s 32-year-old son, Ramsay, went missing in ...
16 Okt 20251h 28min
90 | Robert Eugene Brashers | Yogurt Shop Justice
The three mustaches convene to discuss a shocking breakthrough in a number of decades-old cold cases. After nearly 40 years, the monster responsible for the horrific Yogurt Shop Murders has finally be...
9 Okt 20252h 2min
89 | Laurie Shaver | A Close Shaver
The three mustaches head to the happiest place on Earth to dig up some dirt on the disappearance of Michael Shaver. After spending two years sending rude and cryptic messages to his family, the Lake C...
2 Okt 20251h 48min
