First Watch: Montauk Death Mystery & Jack Nicholson’s Grandson in Court
A luxury yacht anchored off Montauk becomes the scene of tragedy when fashion designer Martha Nolan O’Slattara is found dead onboard, and investigators race to piece together who may be responsible. I...
25 Sep 202520min
Night Watch: The Menendez Brothers Fight for a New Trial
The story of the infamous Menendez Brothers re-catapulted into public opinion when Netflix released its “Monsters” limited series last year. In this episode, Katie unpacks the brothers’ case from its ...
24 Sep 202523min
First Watch: The Devil’s Den Murderer & Nicholas Rossi’s Web of Lies
A family was brutally attacked while hiking on Devil’s Den State Park in Arkansas, leaving two young girls orphaned. Katie discovers more about the teacher allegedly responsible for taking the lives o...
24 Sep 202528min
Night Watch: Luigi Mangione in Court
Katie dissects the high-profile case of the UnitedHealthcare shooter, Luigi Mangione. Luigi just made a court appearance in New York City, where three rows of supporters came to get a glimpse of him. ...
23 Sep 202522min
First Watch: Teen Kills Uber Driver & Haro Baby Mystery Updates
Sheliky Sanchez is the teen from Albuquerque, New Mexico who shot and killed his Uber driver to “let off steam.” He just confessed that his killing of Joseph Andrus isn’t his first murder. And in the ...
23 Sep 202521min
Night Watch: The Teen TikTok Killer
In Georgia, a 17-year-old girl named Sarah Grace Patrick is being charged with the deaths of her mother and stepfather. In this episode, Katie traces Sarah’s digital footprint, which investigators say...
22 Sep 202524min
First Watch: Shocking Baby Trafficking Case & Hollywood Couple Slain
A mother of seven in Indiana faces sex trafficking charges after reportedly using SnapChat to traffic her own baby girl. Katie investigates how the woman tried to get away with it by saying her phone ...
22 Sep 202518min
True Crime This Week: Doomsday Cults
These cults leaders promised deliverance from Doomsday...so why did their followers end up dead? Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell built a following on apocalyptic visions and killed two children they bran...
21 Sep 202548min
