First Watch: Oklahoma’s Youthful Offender Controversy: The Jesse Butler Case
In Oklahoma, Katie examines how teenage offender Jesse Butler went from facing nearly a lifetime in prison for brutal attacks on two girls to serving only counseling and community service under youthf...
11 Des 202521min
Night Watch: Caroline Flack: Inside the Media Storm That Destroyed Her
Tonight, Katie revisits the Caroline Flack case from the beginning, tracing her rise through British television to her dream job hosting Love Island UK, and then the December 2019 incident that change...
10 Des 202522min
First Watch: Seattle’s Backyard Attacker, Sorority House Stalker, & a Naked Intruder
Today, Katie reports on violent home intrusions making headlines. First, Seattle police search for a man who beat 88-year-old Emma Cotton and bit off her finger during a brazen backyard robbery. Next,...
10 Des 202518min
Night Watch: Monster on the Highway: The Life and Death of Aileen Wuornos
Tonight, Katie revisits the life of Aileen Wuornos, the abused Michigan girl who grew up hitchhiking, trading sex for survival and cycling through petty crime before becoming one of the most infamous ...
9 Des 202524min
First Watch: TikTok Affair Lawsuit & a DoorDash Delivery Arrest
When influencer Brenay Kennard started posting cozy videos with her cousin-in-law, the truth spilled out online before it ever did at home. Those clips eventually became evidence in a North Carolina c...
9 Des 202519min
Night Watch: Murder, Inheritance, and the Carman Family Mystery
A New England patriarch is gunned down in his New Hampshire home, his daughter disappears during a supposed freak boating accident, and the grandson who stood to inherit millions survives at sea becam...
8 Des 202521min
First Watch: Firing Squad Execution & a Fugitive Grandson on the Run
Today’s first case is about a South Carolina killer who spent 21 years on death row before choosing to die by firing squad in 2025, raising new questions about how the death penalty is carried out. Th...
8 Des 202521min
True Crime This Week: Music Murders
This week on True Crime This Week, host Vanessa Richardson examines two killings that shook the music world — both committed by fans whose admiration turned to obsession.First, in 1980, 25-year-old Ma...
7 Des 202545min
