Episode 77: Heather Elvis
On the night of December 17, 2013, 20-year-old Heather Elvis goes on a first date with a former high school classmate. The two eat dinner, look at Christmas decorations together, and he tries to teach...
25 Feb 202546min
26: Episode 76: Audrey Moate with guest reader Janet Kidder
In 1956, the brutal murder of family man Thomas Hotard at a Louisiana lover’s lane leaves a trail of unanswered questions. Investigators quickly discover a mysterious connection to Audrey Moate, a wom...
18 Feb 202542min
75: Episode 75: Paula Weldon
SummaryIn 1946, Paula Welden, a college student at Bennington College, mysteriously disappears, leaving behind a chilling unsolved case that has haunted the region for decades. As her disappearance un...
11 Feb 202546min
74: Episode 74: Barbara Newhall Follett (Ep 2) with guest reader Kerry O'Malley
Barbara Newhall Follett had published her first novel at 12, traveled the world by 14, and regularly corresponded with scientists, artists, and sailors. So at age 15, when she ran away for the first t...
4 Feb 20251h 6min
73: Episode 73: Barbara Newhall Follett (Ep 1) with guest reader Kerry O'Malley
By age 9, Barbara Newhall Follett had written her first novel draft. By age 12, she’d published it with a major publishing house, selling out of the initial print run before it even made it to stores....
28 Jan 202556min
72: Episode 72: Etta Riel with guest reader Marsha Mason
In November 1934, new mother Etta Riel mysteriously disappears just hours before she’s set to attend a crucial paternity hearing. Her family believes she was preparing to reconcile with the man she cl...
25 Jan 202556min
15: Episode 71: Olga Schultz Mauger with guest reader Susan Ruttan
September 1934, a 21-year-old newlywed, Olga Schultz Mauger, heads to Togwotee Pass in Wyoming to hunt elk on her honeymoon with her new husband. He says he last saw her sitting on a boulder in the mo...
14 Jan 202552min
70: Episode 70: Stepha Henry
Memorial Day weekend in 2007 was supposed to be a weekend of celebration for the Henry sisters. They traveled from New York City to Miami to see friends, family and celebrate the younger sister’s birt...
7 Jan 202547min
