Episode 202: "Operation Santa Claus"
Before 1913, your letter to Santa was basically doomed, destined for destruction due to being undeliverable. If not for one incredible Christmas sprite, that may have remained the case. Discover the e...
1 Des 202547min
Episode 201: "Lost & Found: Carlina White"
A newborn is taken from a Manhattan hospital by someone pretending to be staff. Missing persons cases are often bleak with little to no resolution for the affected families -- but this case is almost ...
24 Nov 202526min
Episode 200: "The Ghostbusters Ruling"
What happens when you try to sell your haunted house but don't adequately disclose its spectral tenants? A very punny lawsuit that you don't have a **ghost** of a chance to win. For Episode 200, we're...
17 Nov 202559min
Episode 199: "The New York Zodiac Killer"
In the early 1990s, a series of seemingly random shootings terrorized New York City. The killer called himself “The Zodiac." Either an homage to the Zodiac Killer of California...or perhaps the same p...
10 Nov 202556min
Episode 198: "The Lost Colony of Roanoke"
In 1587, more than a hundred English settlers vanished without a trace from an isolated island off the coast of North Carolina. When their governor, John White, returned three years, the only clue was...
3 Nov 202544min
BONUS: Introducing A Very New York Christmas Podcast
Experience the magic of the holiday season in New York City! From the sparkling lights of Rockefeller Center to the iconic Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, discover how New York’s traditions have helpe...
29 Okt 202557s
Episode 197: "The Tombs: Horror in New York’s Most Notorious Jail"
Beneath the streets of Lower Manhattan lies a legacy built on corruption, misery, and decay. Known for nearly two centuries as “The Tombs,” New York City’s infamous municipal jail has seen it all — fr...
27 Okt 202546min
Episode 196: "The Trials of Polly Bodine"
Polly Bodine was everything a woman shouldn't be in the 1840s: a single mother with a boyfriend who drank gin. When her sister-in-law and niece are brutally murdered, it doesn't take long for her neig...
20 Okt 202554min
