Doug and Ashley Benefield- Part 1
Listen as Melissa tells Daniel part one of the case that captivated a nation. The Black Swan Murder. I had a feeling this was going to anger and fascinate Daniel so be prepared for lots of conversatio...
11 Feb 20251h 27min
The MacArthur's Talk Cryptids... Utah!
It's your turn Utah! Listen as Melissa shares 7 of the most popular Cryptids and Legends of the great state of Utah.The MacArthur's go a bit off the rails but 11 of you love that. Enjoy!Send us a text...
5 Feb 202530min
Bob and Colleen Harris with James Batten
Listen as Melissa tells Daniel a crazy case from his old stomping ground. There's so many twists and turns you are going to be saying "what" right along with Daniel. In January of 2013, a call comes i...
28 Jan 20251h 14min
After The Show - Episode 136: Bob and Colleen Harris
Welcome to our very first "After the Show" episode. Listen as we discuss the case unfiltered and unedited. These are the conversation's we have after we hit stop. Only this time we kept recording. Mig...
28 Jan 202516min
The MacArthur's Talk Haunted Locations... Florida!
Oh boy Florida! You've got some strange occurrences. And a cursed doll. Good for you!Send us a textSupport the show Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about ...
21 Jan 202533min
Mitesh and Jessica Patel
This case is awful and open to a lot of opinions and discussion. But, the fact is a beautiful soul was murdered by a selfish and pathetic spouse. Listen as Melissa tells Daniel a case out of the Unite...
14 Jan 20251h 12min
The MacArthur's Talk Cryptids... Florida
You finally made it up to bat Florida! And you hit it out of the park. Had so much fun discussing your cryptids. Lots of annoying laughter in this one. And even a couple of sexual inuendo's. Please en...
8 Jan 202543min
Dominique and Gisele Pelicot plus The Murder of Jorge Torres Jr.
These two cases were by far the most requested and sent to us in some fashion during 2024. I've been sitting on these cases for a while, but I wanted to wait to share them with our 11 listeners until ...
1 Jan 20251h 2min
