236 - Catherine Carroll
Lauren and Christy deep dive the 1991 murder of Catherine Carroll in Newfoundland, Canada. Christy's research reveals police desperate to solve the case at any cost and a killer who waited decades to ...
4 Nov 20251h 47min
235 - Halloween BOOtenanny
In their first annual Halloween BOOtenanny, Lauren and Christy go all in on spooky season with ridiculous costumes, creepy stories sent in from the dear listeners, and a special Halloween bracket to d...
28 Okt 20252h 2min
234 - Texas Cheerleader Murder Plot
Lauren and Christy deep dive the 2024 Investigation Discovery documentary The Texas Cheerleader Murder Plot. Christy's research reveals multiple trials, SO many marriages, and some hard truths about c...
21 Okt 20251h 47min
233 - Girly Chew Hossencofft
Lauren and Christy deep dive the 1999 disappearance and likely murder of Girly Chew Hossencofft. Christy's research reveals an immediate response from police, an alien conspiracy, and a sadistic conma...
14 Okt 20251h 59min
232 - Amy Bradley
Lauren and Christy deep dive the 1998 cruise ship disappearance of Amy Bradley. Christy's research reveals the family's lawsuit against the cruise line, the brother's new theories decades later, and a...
7 Okt 20252h 10min
231 - Birgit Meier
Lauren and Christy deep dive the 1989 disappearance of Birgit Meier. Christy's research reveals a frustrating response by police, a terrifying suspect, and a brother who won't rest until the case is s...
23 Sep 20252h 7min
230 - Unknown Number: The High School Catfish
Lauren and Christy deep dive the 2025 Netflix documentary Unknown Number: The High School Catfish. Christy's research reveals disturbing texts, even more lies, and more unsettling behavior from the cu...
16 Sep 20252h 7min
229 - Peter Falconio
Lauren and Christy deep dive the 2001 disappearance and possible murder of Peter Falconio. Christy's research reveals questionable DNA evidence, a possible witness account that was ignored, and other ...
9 Sep 20251h 58min
