127 | Susan Monica | Like Lipstick on a Pig... Farmer
The three mustaches head to rural Oregon to help track down a guy named Robert Haney. According to his enchantingly beautiful landlord / employer, Susan Monica, he went hog wild a few months ago and s...
2 Juli 1h 33min
125 | Joyce McKinney | The Manacled Mormon Part One
The three mustaches head to jolly old England to cover the controversial case of the Manacled Mormon. In 1977, an American missionary named Kirk Anderson vanished from a Latter-day Saints church in Su...
29 Juni 1h 38min
126 | Joyce McKinney | The Manacled Mormon Part Two
The three mustaches reconvene to finish the scandalous tale of Joyce McKinney and the Manacled Mormon. When we last left off, Joyce and her friend-zoned lackey, Keith May, had just been arrested for t...
25 Juni 1h 43min
124 | Timothy Molnar | Into the Waukesha
The OG mustaches are joined by their new producer, Bluke, to discuss the mysterious disappearance of Timothy Molnar. In 1984, Tim left his home in Daytona Beach, Florida, to attend classes at Embry-Ri...
11 Juni 1h 14min
123 | Helle Crafts | Body Parts and Crafts
The three mustaches convene for one last episode in Texas before moving to their new studio. To mark the occasion, they have chosen an exceptionally "chilling" case. In 1986, a flight attendant named ...
4 Juni 1h 27min
122 | The Evidence Locker | Smiley Face Killer
The mustache mafia is setting up shop in a new studio in North Carolina! To give them time to finish decorating the new studio -- and bury the bodies of the previous tenants -- we present to you an ep...
28 Maj 1h 41min
121 | Kathy Middleton | Butterfingers in Blue Springs
The three mustaches tackle a controversial case from Blue Springs, Missouri involving a highly suspicious accident. On a sunny afternoon in February of 1990, a single gunshot rang out from the home of...
21 Maj 1h 35min
120 | The Gilgo Beach Killer | Part Two: Hunting an Ogre
The three mustaches return to Long Island to conclude their hunt for the Gilgo Beach Killer. After pulling over a dozen bodies from the sand, the Long Island Police Department were able connect at lea...
14 Maj 1h 12min
