Tony Costa, The Cape Cod Vampire Part 2
We’re all up in your ear meat for the second time this week, and we’ve brought you the conclusion to the tale of Tony Chop Chop. Please whip out a notebook and get ready to write as fast as humanly po...
21 Dec 20201h 19min
Tony Costa, The Cape Cod Vampire Part 1
This week Alaina’s got a two parter, pretty close to home for us! Tony Costa, a hippie living around Provincetown in the 60’s, was a real shady character from the start. When he was a teenager he stra...
18 Dec 20201h 25min
"The Meaning Of Christmas" By Jon Allen Bonus Episode!!
Weirdos! Just in time for the holidays, Jon Allen has blessed us with another tale straight from his brilliant mind. "The Meaning of Christmas" is a 90s throwback thriller with an ending that will blo...
16 Dec 20201h 2min
Listener Tales 22
December’s listener tales are coming in hot, weirdos! You guys are so good at these and have us cracking up as usual. We’re talking about our powers of summoning dead grandmas, christmas decorations f...
13 Dec 202055min
The Horrific Kidnapping & Murder of Sarah Haley Foxwell
It was Christmastime 2009 and eleven year old Sarah Haley Foxwell was getting ready to celebrate with her family. She and her little sister skipped off to bed together, but that would be the last time...
11 Dec 202058min
The Tragic Murder of Sarah Ludemann
This week Alaina covers a tale as old as time but with a modern MySpace twist. Two girls fighting over one dingus of a boy. Rachel Wade was living her best Bad Girls Club life, dating the quintessenti...
6 Dec 20201h 5min
The Horrific Murder of Dorothy Stratten
Ash wanted to dive into a vintage Hollywood case this week, and the Dorothy Stratten case stuck out like a sore thumb! Dorothy Stratten was 17 years old working behind the counter at a Dairy Queen in ...
4 Dec 20201h 9min
Martha Haney
It's another old timey murder from Alaina! But trust us, this one will have your jaw hitting the floor. Way back in 1897 Michigan, Martha Haney's struggle with her own illness reached the point of no ...
29 Nov 20201h 11min
