Episode 40. Lucullus and the Eastern Wars: The General Who Won Everything and Lost His Command

Sources and Historiography

Plutarch's Life of Lucullus is the primary source, paired in the Parallel Lives with Cimon of Athens. It is one of Plutarch's more structurally interesting Lives because the two-part arc—military and political in the first half, luxurious retirement in the second—is explicit in Plutarch's own framing. He uses the ancient comedy analogy directly. The Life is notably stronger on the eastern campaigns than on the retirement, and scholars have observed that Plutarch had access to lost works about Lucullus, probably including the Lucullus of Varro's biographical compendium.

Cicero's De Imperio Cn. Pompei is an important document for this episode on two counts: it is a genuinely careful assessment of Lucullus's generalship by a contemporary who had reasons both to praise and to diminish it, and it is the key text for understanding how the transfer of command to Pompey was justified politically. Cicero's praise of Lucullus as fortis vir, sapiens homo, magnus imperator is genuine; his argument that the situation requires Pompey is politically calculated. Reading the two layers simultaneously is instructive.

The cherry attribution is in Pliny's Natural History and is generally accepted by modern scholars. The town of Cerasus in Pontus—modern Giresun in Turkey—is the etymological source of the Latin cerasus, the French cerise, the German Kirsche, the English cherry. Pliny was writing about a century after Lucullus and is not infallible, but the botanical history of the sour cherry's spread through Europe aligns with the Roman period, and no better explanation for the introduction has been proposed. It is as close to certain as botanical history gets for the ancient world.

Works CitedPrimary Sources

• Appian. Mithridatica. The military narrative of the eastern wars.
• Cicero. De Imperio Cn. Pompei. The transfer of command; genuine praise and political calculation combined.
• Pliny. Natural History. The cherry import; the most specific ancient source.
• Plutarch. “Life of Lucullus.” The full portrait from Social War through the retirement and banquets.

Secondary Sources

• Fratantuono, Lee. Lucullus: The Life and Campaigns of a Roman Conqueror. 2017. The most thorough modern English biography.
• Goldsworthy, Adrian. Caesar. 2006. Context on the political world Lucullus moved in and withdrew from.
• Holland, Tom. Rubicon. 2003. Readable account of the period; good on Lucullus's place in the late Republican crisis.
• Matyszak, Philip. Mithridates the Great. 2008. The opponent's perspective throughout the eastern wars.

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/real-roman-history/donations