The Road Less Traveled: How M. Scott Peck Rewrote Robert Frost's 1915 Poem

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Ask people to name Robert Frost's most famous poem and most will say The Road Less Traveled, but no such poem exists. Frost's 1915 poem is titled The Road Not Taken. This episode uses a single Wikipedia disambiguation page as a map of how a misremembered line spread through a century of culture. The turning point came in 1978, when psychiatrist M. Scott Peck titled his bestselling book on psychology and spiritual growth The Road Less Traveled. The hosts argue the small change in wording flipped the meaning: Frost's title looks back at a choice left behind, while Peck's points to the harder road a person is actively walking, a framing that suited the inward turn of the late 1970s.

From there the phrase became a blank canvas for the music industry. Preston Reed, Melissa Etheridge, George Strait, Lauren Alaina, Boyce Avenue and the hardcore punk band Sick of It All all used it, each bending it to their genre: the country outlaw, the pop coming-of-age story, the punk act of defiance. Science fiction television took it literally, with episodes of The Twilight Zone, Battlestar Galactica and The Man in the High Castle exploring parallel paths. A 2012 documentary about Barack Obama's presidency then rewrote it as The Road We've Traveled, turning an anthem of individualism into a story of collective history.

• Preston Reed released a Road Less Traveled album in 1987, and Melissa Etheridge used the title for her 2005 greatest hits collection.
• George Strait released The Road Less Traveled in 2001, and Lauren Alaina used the title for a 2015 song and a 2017 album.
• Sick of It All put a song called Road Less Traveled on its 2014 album The Last Act of Defiance.
• The Twilight Zone (1986), Battlestar Galactica (2008) and The Man in the High Castle (2016) each aired an episode with the title.
• The hosts close by asking whether a phrase used by everyone to declare individuality has become the most crowded path of all.