69. The Disappearance of Evelyn Hartley
🔪 This week, Lauren tells Scar about the disappearance of Evelyn Hartley! Evelyn took a baby sitting job for a new family in town and mysteriously vanished, seeming without a trace. The detectives pu...
22 Aug 20241h 18min
68. The Horrific Crime of Mackenzie Shirilla
WE'VE GOT A SCARDUST EPISODE Y'ALL!! This week, Dustin tells Scar the truly horrific tale of 17 year old Mackenzie Shirilla.. and how the lives of two innocent young men were taken out of this world f...
24 Juli 202454min
67. The Devastating Murder of Sania Khan
This week, Scar tells Lauren the truly tragic story of Sania Khan. Sania was a free spirited young woman, who really knew herself and what she wanted out of life, when fate turned for the worse throug...
13 Juli 20241h 35min
66. The Kidnapping of Eduardo and Jayne Valseca
🔪 WE'VE DONE A RE-BRAND, Y'ALL!!!! WELCOME TO CLAW & ORDER!!!! With you hosts, Scar and Lauren! To kick off our new name, Scar tells Lauren the truly horrific story of the Valseca family in San Migue...
5 Juli 20241h 39min
65. The Tragic Murders of Shari Smith and Debra Helmick : #Sharichard
🔪 This week, we're going to Lexington, South Carolina to discuss the tragic tale of Shari Smith and Debra May Helmick (and possibly more victims).. who were murdered by the hands of a truly horrific ...
27 Juni 20241h 35min
64. The Murder of Amanda Gonzales : #OmelettesAreJustEggs
🔪 WE'VE GOT A NEW CO-HOST, Y'ALL!!! This week, Laur will be telling Scar the tragic tale of Amanda Gonzales, a military girl after our own hearts. Amanda knew what she wanted do with her life from a ...
16 Juni 20241h 10min
63. The Texas Rodeo Queen Murder : #IsDeeForDonna?!
🔪 This week, we're going to Texas, Y'ALL!! Dustin tells Scar the truly devastating tale of the Frazier family.. Turns out there was a rotten apple in this picturesque rodeo family, and it overall jus...
30 Maj 202459min
62. The Heartbreaking Murder of Effie (Williams) Ratley : #ThatHeWoreARobe?
🔪 This week, Scar tells Dustin the truly heart wrenching tale of Effie (Williams) Ratley! Effie was viciously attacked while sleeping in the home of her husbands parents house.. due to an earlier-fir...
23 Maj 202448min
